NI Holdings NODK Peer Comparison

NASDAQ NODK
$15.34 +0.33 (+2.20%)
At close: Sep 2, 2026 · 4:00 PM EDT
Peer Comparison

127 Comparable Companies

Industry Property and Casualty Insurance

NI Holdings, Inc. (NODK) is the 111th largest of 127 Property and Casualty Insurance companies by market capitalisation, at 315.97 Mn, behind Lesaka Technologies Inc at 360.12 Mn. It trades on a P/E of 40.34, 281% above the peer median of 10.59. The table below compares all 127 on 8 financial metrics.

Download Data
# Ticker Company match industry_code industry_group industry_group_code Market Capitalization P/E P/S Enterprise Value
1 CB Chubb Ltd primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 131.15 Bn 11.40 2.12 117.38 Bn
2 TRV Travelers Companies, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 76.99 Bn 9.27 1.57 53.24 Bn
3 ALL Allstate Corp primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 66.35 Bn 5.03 0.95 27.62 Bn
4 AFL Aflac Inc primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 59.03 Bn 12.74 3.27 -43.97 Bn
5 AIG American International Group, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 40.28 Bn 13.59 1.51 2.47 Bn
6 HIG Hartford Insurance Group, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 37.47 Bn 8.63 1.29 21.16 Bn
7 FRFHF Fairfax Financial Holdings Ltd/ Can primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 35.82 Bn 0.45 — 35.82 Bn
8 CINF Cincinnati Financial Corp primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 26.40 Bn 8.14 1.89 24.51 Bn
9 MKL Markel Group Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 22.75 Bn 9.92 1.47 5.86 Bn
10 L Loews Corp primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 22.37 Bn 12.50 1.20 0.07 Bn
11 UNM Unum Group primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 14.81 Bn 16.23 1.11 5.26 Bn
12 AIZ Assurant, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 14.04 Bn 13.21 1.04 12.01 Bn
13 CNA Cna Financial Corp primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 13.14 Bn 10.63 0.87 5.36 Bn
14 AFG American Financial Group Inc primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 11.82 Bn 13.54 1.43 -6.03 Bn
15 ORI Old Republic International Corp primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 10.06 Bn 8.81 1.03 10.06 Bn
16 KNSL Kinsale Capital Group, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 8.56 Bn 15.05 4.29 7.58 Bn
17 THG Hanover Insurance Group, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 7.93 Bn 10.54 1.17 1.69 Bn
18 AXS Axis Capital Holdings Ltd primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 7.32 Bn 6.81 1.08 6.54 Bn
19 WRB-PF Berkley W R Corp primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 6.99 Bn 3.61 0.47 2.88 Bn
20 ACT Enact Holdings, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 6.79 Bn 9.94 5.42 6.30 Bn
21 MTG Mgic Investment Corp primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 6.51 Bn 9.20 5.45 6.29 Bn
22 ESNT Essent Group Ltd. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 6.27 Bn 9.21 4.74 6.27 Bn
23 RLI Rli Corp primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 5.82 Bn 13.26 2.95 -0.02 Bn
24 MCY Mercury General Corp primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 5.70 Bn 6.08 0.90 -16.17 Bn
25 FTDR Frontdoor, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 5.68 Bn 20.79 2.64 5.05 Bn
26 SIGI Selective Insurance Group Inc primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 5.50 Bn 11.26 1.00 3.40 Bn
27 WTM White Mountains Insurance Group Ltd primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 5.10 Bn 4.32 1.33 -6.31 Bn
28 RDN Radian Group Inc primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 4.93 Bn 9.19 3.00 4.19 Bn
29 ARX Accelerant Holdings primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 4.31 Bn -3.16 3.76 2.66 Bn
30 LMND Lemonade, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 4.08 Bn -29.49 4.19 3.69 Bn
31 GNW Genworth Financial Inc primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 3.84 Bn 11.24 0.52 1.86 Bn
32 HG Hamilton Insurance Group, Ltd. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 3.51 Bn 4.07 1.17 -0.68 Bn
33 PLMR Palomar Holdings, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 3.47 Bn 17.10 3.18 3.36 Bn
34 NMIH NMI Holdings, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 3.38 Bn 8.55 4.63 3.31 Bn
35 AGO Assured Guaranty Ltd primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 3.32 Bn 8.67 3.53 -0.48 Bn
36 SLDE Slide Insurance Holdings, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 2.79 Bn 5.01 2.01 1.55 Bn
37 PLGO Pelagos Insurance Capital Ltd primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 2.64 Bn 5.10 1.05 3.92 Bn
38 SKWD Skyward Specialty Insurance Group, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 2.51 Bn 13.35 1.45 1.90 Bn
39 HCI HCI Group, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 2.29 Bn 6.71 2.41 1.36 Bn
40 HMN Horace Mann Educators Corp /De/ primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 2.11 Bn 11.88 1.21 -3.71 Bn
41 PRCH Porch Group, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 1.98 Bn -222.45 3.80 1.78 Bn
42 SAFT Safety Insurance Group Inc primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 1.51 Bn 22.58 1.17 1.24 Bn
43 KMPB KEMPER Corp primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 1.44 Bn -2.85 0.31 0.15 Bn
44 UFCS United Fire Group Inc primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 1.41 Bn 9.99 0.96 1.27 Bn
45 ASIC Ategrity Specialty Insurance Co Holdings primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 1.29 Bn 11.24 2.49 1.02 Bn
46 TRUP Trupanion, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 1.24 Bn 53.52 0.82 0.84 Bn
47 UVE Universal Insurance Holdings, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 1.21 Bn 5.51 0.74 0.57 Bn
48 IGIC International General Insurance Holdings Ltd. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 1.14 Bn 0.42 19.47 0.91 Bn
49 BOW Bowhead Specialty Holdings Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 1.11 Bn 17.82 1.80 0.97 Bn
50 HRTG Heritage Insurance Holdings, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 1.03 Bn 4.79 1.21 0.32 Bn
51 EIG Employers Holdings, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 0.90 Bn 118.27 1.07 0.61 Bn
52 HIPO Hippo Holdings Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 0.89 Bn 7.31 1.75 0.58 Bn
53 ROOT Root, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 0.86 Bn 14.84 0.55 0.34 Bn
54 BRK-B Berkshire Hathaway Inc primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 0.73 Bn 0.01 0.00 -326.25 Bn
55 DGICA Donegal Group Inc primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 0.72 Bn 11.72 0.74 0.69 Bn
56 TIPT Tiptree Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 0.69 Bn 17.15 — 0.64 Bn
57 AII American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 0.51 Bn 5.31 1.59 0.21 Bn
58 AMSF Amerisafe Inc primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 0.48 Bn 10.42 1.44 0.35 Bn
59 ACIC AMERICAN COASTAL INSURANCE Corp primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 0.45 Bn 4.51 1.37 0.08 Bn
60 GBLI Global Indemnity Group, LLC primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 0.41 Bn 22.26 — 0.31 Bn
61 NODK NI Holdings, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 0.32 Bn 40.34 1.18 -0.06 Bn
62 KINS Kingstone Companies, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 0.29 Bn 8.12 1.21 0.27 Bn
63 MBI Mbia Inc primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 0.24 Bn -238.70 34.10 -0.11 Bn
64 OSG Octave Specialty Group Inc primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 0.20 Bn -1.24 0.63 -0.09 Bn
65 JRVR James River Group Holdings, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 0.19 Bn 8.34 0.29 -0.01 Bn
66 AAME Atlantic American Corp primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 0.03 Bn 5.96 0.13 -0.01 Bn
67 PRHI Presurance Holdings, Inc. primary F-13 Insurance FG-04 0.02 Bn -2.04 0.75 -0.05 Bn
68 CAT Caterpillar Inc secondary I-05 Machinery IG-02 364.77 Bn 33.64 4.88 358.05 Bn
69 RY Royal Bank Of Canada secondary F-02 Banking FG-01 292.90 Bn 17.85 5.70 66.02 Bn
70 TD Toronto Dominion Bank secondary F-02 Banking FG-01 209.66 Bn 18.61 4.48 48.33 Bn
71 BBVA Banco Bilbao Vizcaya Argentaria, S.A. secondary F-02 Banking FG-01 167.73 Bn 12.71 9.69 -115.27 Bn
72 KKR KKR & Co. Inc. secondary F-11 Asset and Wealth Management FG-03 95.73 Bn 32.01 4.49 -181.34 Bn
73 BN BROOKFIELD Corp /ON/ secondary F-11 Asset and Wealth Management FG-03 89.55 Bn 71.24 1.16 42.14 Bn
74 UPS United Parcel Service Inc secondary I-23 Transportation IG-05 87.67 Bn 19.18 0.97 83.02 Bn
75 LLDTF Lloyds Banking Group plc secondary F-02 Banking FG-01 85.81 Bn 21.39 2.53 86.12 Bn
76 GGAL Grupo Financiero Galicia Sa secondary F-02 Banking FG-01 72.25 Bn 0.22 — 72.25 Bn
77 MET Metlife Inc secondary F-12 Insurance FG-04 61.95 Bn 18.00 0.78 34.63 Bn
78 PSA Public Storage secondary R-08 Property REITs RG-01 52.77 Bn 28.60 10.79 52.51 Bn
79 SHG Shinhan Financial Group Co Ltd secondary F-02 Banking FG-01 39.65 Bn 12.25 2.03 13.51 Bn
80 BAP Credicorp Ltd secondary F-02 Banking FG-01 30.13 Bn 1.90 4.87 30.13 Bn
81 EXR Extra Space Storage Inc. secondary R-08 Property REITs RG-01 29.50 Bn 33.39 8.56 29.50 Bn
82 PFG Principal Financial Group Inc secondary F-09 Asset and Wealth Management FG-03 24.05 Bn 15.24 1.53 -28.92 Bn
83 BRO Brown & Brown, Inc. secondary F-16 Insurance FG-04 23.99 Bn 19.78 3.53 23.07 Bn
84 CG Carlyle Group Inc. secondary F-11 Asset and Wealth Management FG-03 16.87 Bn 31.20 4.67 15.62 Bn
85 RGA Reinsurance Group Of America Inc secondary F-15 Insurance FG-04 16.34 Bn 10.79 0.63 10.68 Bn
86 EG Everest Group, Ltd. secondary F-15 Insurance FG-04 14.66 Bn 7.66 0.87 -32.71 Bn
87 RNR Renaissancere Holdings Ltd secondary F-15 Insurance FG-04 13.69 Bn 5.27 1.23 -12.80 Bn
88 ALLY Ally Financial Inc. secondary F-02 Banking FG-01 13.16 Bn 9.90 1.52 5.32 Bn
89 FRHC Freedom Holding Corp. secondary F-02 Banking FG-01 10.28 Bn 66.50 4.30 10.28 Bn
90 VOYA Voya Financial, Inc. secondary F-09 Asset and Wealth Management FG-03 9.32 Bn 16.44 1.14 6.97 Bn
91 BNT Brookfield Wealth Solutions Ltd. secondary F-12 Insurance FG-04 8.95 Bn 71.57 0.75 -3.83 Bn
92 WAL Western Alliance Bancorporation secondary F-01 Banking FG-01 8.53 Bn 8.72 2.17 2.51 Bn
93 LNC Lincoln National Corp secondary F-12 Insurance FG-04 8.50 Bn 3.75 0.44 -3.18 Bn
94 TMHC Taylor Morrison Home Corp secondary D-08 Homebuilding DG-03 6.77 Bn 10.26 0.89 6.12 Bn
95 CACC Credit Acceptance Corp secondary F-04 Lending and Credit FG-02 6.36 Bn 14.03 2.73 5.87 Bn
96 IFS Intercorp Financial Services Inc. secondary F-02 Banking FG-01 6.21 Bn 0.14 — -79.68 Bn
97 LSTR Landstar System Inc secondary I-22 Transportation IG-05 5.92 Bn 44.96 1.19 5.57 Bn
98 RYAN Ryan Specialty Holdings, Inc. secondary F-16 Insurance FG-04 5.31 Bn 21.85 1.65 5.17 Bn
99 PFH Prudential Financial Inc secondary F-12 Insurance FG-04 5.28 Bn 1.35 0.08 -26.64 Bn
100 ATH-PA Athene Holding Ltd. secondary F-12 Insurance FG-04 4.60 Bn 6.65 0.16 -3.30 Bn
101 CVCO Cavco Industries, Inc. secondary D-09 Homebuilding DG-03 4.38 Bn 29.56 — 4.12 Bn
102 HHH Howard Hughes Holdings Inc. secondary R-18 Property Developers RG-05 3.73 Bn 12.84 1.57 3.73 Bn
103 FG F&G Annuities & Life, Inc. secondary F-12 Insurance FG-04 3.11 Bn 7.75 0.51 0.46 Bn
104 BHF Brighthouse Financial, Inc. secondary F-12 Insurance FG-04 3.08 Bn 4.23 0.46 -4.98 Bn
105 BOH Bank Of Hawaii Corp secondary F-01 Banking FG-01 3.01 Bn 14.06 3.96 -0.73 Bn
106 BWIN Baldwin Insurance Group, Inc. secondary F-16 Insurance FG-04 2.87 Bn -21.53 1.65 2.69 Bn
107 SPNT SiriusPoint Ltd secondary F-15 Insurance FG-04 2.84 Bn 5.73 0.87 2.16 Bn
108 OFG Ofg Bancorp secondary F-01 Banking FG-01 2.23 Bn 10.10 2.98 1.48 Bn
109 STBA S&T Bancorp Inc secondary F-01 Banking FG-01 1.78 Bn 12.66 96.22 0.55 Bn
110 HGTY Hagerty, Inc. secondary F-16 Insurance FG-04 1.34 Bn 21.54 0.93 1.04 Bn
111 UHAL U-Haul Holding Co /NV/ secondary D-21 Travel and Lodging DG-07 1.30 Bn 4.58 — -2.37 Bn
112 DFH Dream Finders Homes, Inc. secondary D-08 Homebuilding DG-03 1.23 Bn 8.35 0.30 1.03 Bn
113 GL-PD Globe Life Inc. secondary F-12 Insurance FG-04 1.14 Bn 0.94 0.18 0.38 Bn
114 CCNE Cnb Financial Corp/Pa secondary F-01 Banking FG-01 1.00 Bn 10.89 2.98 0.53 Bn
115 GLRE Greenlight Capital Re, Ltd. secondary F-15 Insurance FG-04 0.50 Bn 9.88 0.69 -0.20 Bn
116 TWFG TWFG, Inc. secondary F-16 Insurance FG-04 0.39 Bn 7.02 1.33 0.30 Bn
117 LSAK Lesaka Technologies Inc secondary F-04 Lending and Credit FG-02 0.36 Bn -12.61 0.51 0.27 Bn
118 RM Regional Management Corp. secondary F-04 Lending and Credit FG-02 0.30 Bn 6.33 0.44 0.18 Bn
119 LARK Landmark Bancorp Inc secondary F-01 Banking FG-01 0.19 Bn 13.68 2.25 0.19 Bn
120 SBFG Sb Financial Group, Inc. secondary F-01 Banking FG-01 0.18 Bn 10.70 -19.52 0.06 Bn
121 OZSC Ozop Energy Solutions, Inc. secondary I-45 Clean Energy Equipment IG-10 0.13 Bn -23.54 — 0.13 Bn
122 CITR CitroTech Inc. secondary M-02 Chemicals MG-01 0.12 Bn -3.84 91.05 0.12 Bn
123 SIEB Siebert Financial Corp secondary F-19 Capital Markets FG-05 0.10 Bn -90.21 0.96 -0.10 Bn
124 PFX PhenixFIN Corp secondary F-07 Lending and Credit FG-02 0.09 Bn 4.07 9.41 -0.21 Bn
125 KG Kestrel Group Ltd secondary F-16 Insurance FG-04 0.06 Bn -1.59 1.37 0.03 Bn
126 MLCI Mount Logan Capital Inc. secondary F-11 Asset and Wealth Management FG-03 0.04 Bn -0.63 0.78 -0.06 Bn
127 OXBR OXBRIDGE RE HOLDINGS Ltd secondary F-15 Insurance FG-04 0.01 Bn 28.74 3.94 -0.01 Bn