Cracker Barrel Old Country Store, Inc (CBRL) Stock Analysis and Metrics

Cracker Barrel Old Country Store

NASDAQ: CBRL

$53.72 ▲ +1.90 (+3.67%)

At close: Jul 24, 2026 · 3:59 PM UTC

Financial Ratios

Market Cap1.20 Bn

P/E80.94

P/S0.36

Div. Yield0.02

ROIC (Qtr)0.00

Total Debt (Qtr)486.63 Mn

Revenue Growth (1y) (Qtr)-2.90

Add ratio to table…

About

Cracker Barrel Old Country Store, Inc. operates and develops the Cracker Barrel Old Country Store concept, which combines a full service restaurant with a retail gift shop offering home style country food and a variety of nostalgic merchandise. The company is headquartered in Lebanon, Tennessee and maintains a website at crackerbarrel.com. As of September 12, 2025, it operated 657 Cracker Barrel stores across 43 states and 68 Maple Street Biscuit Company locations in 10 states. Each Cracker Barrel store follows a prototype of approximately 8,900 square feet, with about 1,900 square feet dedicated to retail selling space and the remainder allocated to restaurant, training and storage areas. The store design features a rustic old country style exterior, stone fireplaces and front porch rocking chairs that are iconic to the brand.

Revenue is generated primarily from food and beverage sales in the restaurants and from merchandise sales in the gift shops. In 2025, restaurant sales represented approximately 81% of total revenue while gift shop sales contributed the remaining 19%. The average check per guest was $15.23, reflecting a 6.8% increase from the prior year, and the typical store served about 5,330 restaurant guests each week. Menu prices ranged from $6.99 to $21.99 for breakfast and from $5.19 to $25.99 for lunch and dinner. Day part distribution of restaurant sales in 2025 was 28% for breakfast, 40% for lunch and 32% for dinner. Gift shop sales were led by apparel and accessories at 33%, food at 18%, toys at 13%, décor at 13% and media at 7%. Off premise channels, which include individual takeout, third party delivery and catering, accounted for roughly 20% of restaurant sales, with individual takeout representing about 50% of that off premise total, third party delivery about 32% and catering and occasion about 18%.

The company operates through the following segments.

• Cracker Barrel Old Country Store: This segment operates full service restaurants that serve breakfast, lunch and dinner daily, offering home style dishes such as pancakes, eggs, meats, grits, biscuit specialties, fried and grilled chicken, meatloaf, country fried steak, pork chops, fish, shrimp, steak, vegetable plates, sandwiches and salads, along with an attached gift shop that sells apparel, accessories, food items, toys, décor and media products.

• Maple Street Biscuit Company: This segment runs a breakfast and lunch fast casual concept with a focus on biscuit inspired entrées, freshly roasted coffee, and a limited selection of beer and wine in select locations, operating primarily during morning and early afternoon hours.

Cracker Barrel Old Country Store, Inc. distinguishes itself through a unique brand that blends a full service restaurant with a retail gift shop evoking nostalgic Americana, which appeals to both travelers and local patrons seeking home style meals and distinctive merchandise. The company competes with national and regional restaurant chains such as Denny’s and Bob Evans, supermarkets offering convenient meal solutions, fast casual and quick service establishments, as well as locally owned restaurants and retail stores. Its competitive advantages stem from a consistent focus on quality, value and friendly service, a loyal customer base reinforced by the Cracker Barrel Rewards program, and a distinctive store atmosphere featuring stone fireplaces, antique style furnishings and front porch rocking chairs that create a memorable dining and shopping experience.

The company serves a broad customer base that includes highway travelers, local families, couples and individuals looking for a relaxed dining experience combined with the opportunity to browse nostalgic gifts. Guests span various age groups and are drawn by the promise of home style cooking, friendly service and the ability to enjoy a meal while seated on the signature rocking chairs on the front porch. While the filing does not disclose specific customer names, the typical patron consists of vacationers, commuters and community members who value the combination of food and retail in a welcoming setting, contributing to repeat visits and brand loyalty.

Investment Thesis

▲ Bull case

Cracker Barrel Old Country Store, Inc. is strategically leveraging its robust loyalty program to drive sustainable traffic growth and operational improvements, with over 11 million members representing more than 40% of tracked sales and traffic among loyalty members holding up better than nonmembers since August 2025. This deepening engagement allows the company to refine marketing messaging, test targeted offers, and increase frequency with its highest-value guests, directly addressing the core challenge of traffic recovery. The program's scale provides a durable competitive advantage in understanding guest behavior and reinforcing value propositions, which management highlighted as a key tool for improving traffic without relying solely on broad-based advertising spend. As the company reduces advertising expenses by $13 million to $17 million in the second half of fiscal 2026, the loyalty program's ability to deliver personalized engagement becomes increasingly critical to maintaining brand awareness and driving visitation, turning a cost-saving measure into a strategic strength that could accelerate the recovery in guest traffic beyond current expectations.
The company's menu innovation and value strategy are creating unappreciated upside through the successful reintroduction of guest favorites and new premium offerings that are outperforming internal expectations, particularly the Breakfast Burger and Carrot Cake, which have driven improved food taste, service, and value scores by 4% to 5% year-over-year in Q2 FY26 with continued improvement into Q3. These menu enhancements are not merely tactical but represent a structural shift toward higher guest satisfaction and mix improvement, as evidenced by the early success of initiatives like the 'Meals for Two' promotion starting at $19.99 and the ability to upgrade to three sides or add soup and salad for $5, which have already improved mix trends. By aligning menu development with guest feedback through Front Porch Feedback and focusing on taste, consistency, and ease of execution, Cracker Barrel is building a self-reinforcing cycle where better food drives traffic, which in turn supports labor efficiency and cost savings, potentially unlocking margin expansion that is not fully captured in the current EBITDA guidance range of $85 million to $100 million for FY26.
Cracker Barrel Old Country Store, Inc. is positioned to benefit from a structural shift in summer travel demand through its 'Fuel Your Summer Road Trip' sweepstakes, which directly addresses the 79% of Americans who say gas prices will impact their summer plans by offering $500 gas cards alongside $500 gift cards to 250 loyalty members weekly from May 19 through July 26, 2026. This initiative leverages the company's unique restaurant-retail integration and strong nostalgia appeal—particularly through the returning Campfire Meals platform—to capture discretionary spending during peak road trip season, converting potential travel hesitation into increased visitation and higher average order values. Unlike temporary promotional tactics, this program is designed to reinforce long-term loyalty engagement by tying rewards to qualifying entrée purchases and retail add-ons, creating a sustained mechanism to drive frequency and basket size that could meaningfully improve Q3 and Q4 FY26 performance beyond the current traffic guidance of negative 8.5% to negative 9.5% for the full year, especially as the company comps against a relatively weaker Q3 FY25.

Cracker Barrel Old Country Store, Inc. is strategically leveraging its robust loyalty program to drive sustainable traffic growth and operational improvements, with over 11 million members representing more than 40% of tracked sales and traffic among loyalty members holding up better than nonmembers since August 2025. This deepening engagement allows the company to refine marketing messaging, test targeted offers, and increase frequency with its highest-value guests, directly addressing the core challenge of traffic recovery. The program's scale provides a durable competitive advantage in understanding guest behavior and reinforcing value propositions, which management highlighted as a key tool for improving traffic without relying solely on broad-based advertising spend. As the company reduces advertising expenses by $13 million to $17 million in the second half of fiscal 2026, the loyalty program's ability to deliver personalized engagement becomes increasingly critical to maintaining brand awareness and driving visitation, turning a cost-saving measure into a strategic strength that could accelerate the recovery in guest traffic beyond current expectations.
The company's menu innovation and value strategy are creating unappreciated upside through the successful reintroduction of guest favorites and new premium offerings that are outperforming internal expectations, particularly the Breakfast Burger and Carrot Cake, which have driven improved food taste, service, and value scores by 4% to 5% year-over-year in Q2 FY26 with continued improvement into Q3. These menu enhancements are not merely tactical but represent a structural shift toward higher guest satisfaction and mix improvement, as evidenced by the early success of initiatives like the 'Meals for Two' promotion starting at $19.99 and the ability to upgrade to three sides or add soup and salad for $5, which have already improved mix trends. By aligning menu development with guest feedback through Front Porch Feedback and focusing on taste, consistency, and ease of execution, Cracker Barrel is building a self-reinforcing cycle where better food drives traffic, which in turn supports labor efficiency and cost savings, potentially unlocking margin expansion that is not fully captured in the current EBITDA guidance range of $85 million to $100 million for FY26.
Cracker Barrel Old Country Store, Inc. is positioned to benefit from a structural shift in summer travel demand through its 'Fuel Your Summer Road Trip' sweepstakes, which directly addresses the 79% of Americans who say gas prices will impact their summer plans by offering $500 gas cards alongside $500 gift cards to 250 loyalty members weekly from May 19 through July 26, 2026. This initiative leverages the company's unique restaurant-retail integration and strong nostalgia appeal—particularly through the returning Campfire Meals platform—to capture discretionary spending during peak road trip season, converting potential travel hesitation into increased visitation and higher average order values. Unlike temporary promotional tactics, this program is designed to reinforce long-term loyalty engagement by tying rewards to qualifying entrée purchases and retail add-ons, creating a sustained mechanism to drive frequency and basket size that could meaningfully improve Q3 and Q4 FY26 performance beyond the current traffic guidance of negative 8.5% to negative 9.5% for the full year, especially as the company comps against a relatively weaker Q3 FY25.

▼ Bear case

Cracker Barrel Old Country Store, Inc. faces significant and underappreciated pressure from evolving labor dynamics that could erode profitability despite current cost-saving initiatives, as evidenced by the 170 basis point increase in labor and related expenses to 36.1% of revenue in Q2 FY26, driven by sales deleverage and lower productivity, with wage inflation at approximately 2%. While management cites corporate restructuring for annualized G&A savings of $20 million to $25 million, the persistent struggle with hourly and manager turnover—despite a reported 10% improvement in management turnover year-over-year—suggests deeper operational challenges in maintaining consistent service quality and labor efficiency, particularly as the company attempts to scale complex menu innovations like the Breakfast Burger and Smoky Southern Salmon. The reliance on labor-intensive scratch-cooked food and table service model makes the business inherently vulnerable to wage pressure and productivity fluctuations, which could undermine the expected benefits from menu mix improvements and value promotions if labor costs continue to rise faster than sales growth, potentially keeping adjusted EBITDA margins below the 4.4% achieved in Q2 FY26 for the full year.
The company's retail segment remains structurally challenged and is unlikely to meaningfully contribute to overall profitability, with total retail revenue decreasing 9.3% to $180.5 million in Q2 FY26 and comparable store retail sales down 9.2%, despite flat retail attachment year-over-year and a slight increase in average order value. Management's focus on mitigating tariffs and managing inventories overlooks the fundamental issue that retail performance has been declining consistently due to traffic dependency, and the segment's high cost of goods sold at 56.8% of retail sales—up 340 basis points from the prior year—reflects ongoing vulnerability to supply chain disruptions and promotional intensity. As the company shifts toward a more targeted advertising approach and reduces spend in the second half of FY26, the retail segment's inability to generate independent traffic or margin expansion poses a persistent drag on overall results, especially given that retail represents over 20% of total revenue and its performance is closely tied to the same traffic trends pressuring the restaurant business, creating a compounding negative effect on leverage and cash flow generation.
Cracker Barrel Old Country Store, Inc.'s guidance assumes a modest tariff impact that may be significantly underestimated given the evolving global trade environment and the company's reliance on a single distribution facility and significant vendors for foreign-sourced retail products, which management acknowledged as a risk factor. While CFO Craig Pommells suggested the tariff impact would be 'a little bit smaller this year' due to lagged supply chain effects and modest rate changes, the retail cost of goods sold increase of 340 basis points in Q2 FY26 was primarily driven by higher tariffs and increased discounts, indicating that tariff pressures are already materially affecting margins. With commodity inflation guided at 2% to 2.5% and hourly inflation at 2.5% to 3% for FY26, any unanticipated escalation in tariff-related costs—particularly if supply chain lags shorten or retaliatory trade measures emerge—could combine with wage and food cost inflation to squeeze margins more severely than anticipated, potentially preventing the company from achieving the higher end of its adjusted EBITDA guidance range and forcing further downward revisions to profitability expectations as the year progresses.

Cracker Barrel Old Country Store, Inc. faces significant and underappreciated pressure from evolving labor dynamics that could erode profitability despite current cost-saving initiatives, as evidenced by the 170 basis point increase in labor and related expenses to 36.1% of revenue in Q2 FY26, driven by sales deleverage and lower productivity, with wage inflation at approximately 2%. While management cites corporate restructuring for annualized G&A savings of $20 million to $25 million, the persistent struggle with hourly and manager turnover—despite a reported 10% improvement in management turnover year-over-year—suggests deeper operational challenges in maintaining consistent service quality and labor efficiency, particularly as the company attempts to scale complex menu innovations like the Breakfast Burger and Smoky Southern Salmon. The reliance on labor-intensive scratch-cooked food and table service model makes the business inherently vulnerable to wage pressure and productivity fluctuations, which could undermine the expected benefits from menu mix improvements and value promotions if labor costs continue to rise faster than sales growth, potentially keeping adjusted EBITDA margins below the 4.4% achieved in Q2 FY26 for the full year.
The company's retail segment remains structurally challenged and is unlikely to meaningfully contribute to overall profitability, with total retail revenue decreasing 9.3% to $180.5 million in Q2 FY26 and comparable store retail sales down 9.2%, despite flat retail attachment year-over-year and a slight increase in average order value. Management's focus on mitigating tariffs and managing inventories overlooks the fundamental issue that retail performance has been declining consistently due to traffic dependency, and the segment's high cost of goods sold at 56.8% of retail sales—up 340 basis points from the prior year—reflects ongoing vulnerability to supply chain disruptions and promotional intensity. As the company shifts toward a more targeted advertising approach and reduces spend in the second half of FY26, the retail segment's inability to generate independent traffic or margin expansion poses a persistent drag on overall results, especially given that retail represents over 20% of total revenue and its performance is closely tied to the same traffic trends pressuring the restaurant business, creating a compounding negative effect on leverage and cash flow generation.
Cracker Barrel Old Country Store, Inc.'s guidance assumes a modest tariff impact that may be significantly underestimated given the evolving global trade environment and the company's reliance on a single distribution facility and significant vendors for foreign-sourced retail products, which management acknowledged as a risk factor. While CFO Craig Pommells suggested the tariff impact would be 'a little bit smaller this year' due to lagged supply chain effects and modest rate changes, the retail cost of goods sold increase of 340 basis points in Q2 FY26 was primarily driven by higher tariffs and increased discounts, indicating that tariff pressures are already materially affecting margins. With commodity inflation guided at 2% to 2.5% and hourly inflation at 2.5% to 3% for FY26, any unanticipated escalation in tariff-related costs—particularly if supply chain lags shorten or retaliatory trade measures emerge—could combine with wage and food cost inflation to squeeze margins more severely than anticipated, potentially preventing the company from achieving the higher end of its adjusted EBITDA guidance range and forcing further downward revisions to profitability expectations as the year progresses.

Segments Breakdown of Revenue (2025)

Peer Comparison

Companies in the Restaurants

S.No.	Ticker	Company	Market Cap	P/E	P/S	Total Debt (Qtr)
1	SBUX	Starbucks Corp	118.28 Bn	79.08	3.07	15.08 Bn
2	YUM	Yum Brands Inc	41.26 Bn	23.74	4.86	11.95 Bn
3	CMG	Chipotle Mexican Grill Inc	41.21 Bn	28.38	3.40	-
4	QSR	Restaurant Brands International Inc.	25.26 Bn	26.45	2.63	13.30 Bn
5	DRI	Darden Restaurants Inc	22.64 Bn	-5,264.33	1.77	2.43 Bn
6	YUMC	Yum China Holdings, Inc.	15.35 Bn	15.43	1.27	0.02 Bn
7	TXRH	Texas Roadhouse, Inc.	12.76 Bn	30.71	2.10	0.05 Bn
8	DPZ	Dominos Pizza Inc	11.11 Bn	14.99	2.21	4.88 Bn

Research Tools

Developers

About

Investment Thesis

Products and Services Breakdown of Revenue (2025)

Segments Breakdown of Revenue (2025)

Peer Comparison

Research Tools

Developers

About

Investment Thesis

Products and Services Breakdown of Revenue (2025)

Segments Breakdown of Revenue (2025)

Peer Comparison

Create an account

Sign In

Reset Password