Cf Bankshares Inc. (CFBK) Stock Analysis and Metrics

Cf Bankshares

NASDAQ: CFBK

$33.33 ▲ +0.66 (+2.02%)

At close: Jul 24, 2026 · 3:59 PM UTC

Financial Ratios

Market Cap216.47 Mn

P/E12.32

P/S3.84

Div. Yield0.01

Total Debt (Qtr)100.97 Mn

Add ratio to table…

About

CF Bankshares Inc. is a Delaware corporation organized in September 1998 as the holding company for CFBank. CFBank is a nationally chartered boutique commercial bank that operates primarily in five major metro markets Columbus Cleveland Cincinnati Akron Ohio and Indianapolis Indiana. The bank provides commercial retail and mortgage lending services along with treasury management depository services online banking mobile banking and remote deposit capabilities. CFBank focuses on serving the financial needs of closely held businesses and entrepreneurs by offering individualized service and direct access to decision makers. At December 31 2025 the Company reported total assets of $2.1 billion and stockholders equity of $184.4 million.

CF Bankshares Inc. generates revenue principally from interest and fees on loans originated and from noninterest income earned on the sale of loans. The Company’s primary sources of funds include retail and business deposit accounts certificates of deposit brokered certificates of deposit principal and interest payments on loans and securities Federal Home Loan Bank advances other borrowings and proceeds from loan sales. Interest income is also derived from the securities available for sale portfolio which includes U. S. Treasury securities and collateralized mortgage obligations. Fee based income arises from treasury management services loan servicing and other banking products offered to customers. The Company’s earnings are influenced by the volume of loan originations the interest rate environment and the level of deposit gathering activities.

CF Bankshares Inc. competes in a highly fragmented financial services market that includes large national banks regional banks credit unions savings institutions mortgage banking companies and brokerage firms. Many of its competitors possess greater financial resources broader product suites and wider geographic reach. The Company differentiates itself by emphasizing personalized service local decision making and a streamlined customer experience that avoids the bureaucracy often associated with larger institutions. Its boutique positioning allows CFBank to respond quickly to the needs of closely held businesses and entrepreneurs while maintaining the sophistication of larger banks through technology offerings such as online and mobile banking platforms. A well capitalized balance sheet and disciplined underwriting practices further support its competitive stance in the Ohio and Indiana markets.

CF Bankshares Inc. serves a customer base consisting primarily of closely held businesses entrepreneurs retail depositors and small business owners operating within its geographic footprint. The Bank attracts customers seeking commercial loans equipment leases commercial and residential real estate mortgages treasury management services and various deposit products. While the filing does not disclose specific customer names it indicates that relationships are built through local loan officers community contacts and existing customer networks. The Company’s focus on understanding the unique financial requirements of its clients helps to foster long term loyalty and repeat business across its lending and deposit lines.

Investment Thesis

▲ Bull case

CFBK's strategic focus on deepening its commercial banking teams across its five major metro markets—Columbus, Cleveland, Cincinnati, Akron, and Indianapolis—represents a high-conviction catalyst for sustained loan growth that the market is underestimating. The Q1 2026 results showed net core commercial loan growth of $45 million, translating to an annualized rate of 15%, despite timing-related headwinds from early-quarter loan payoffs. Management explicitly noted that heavier loan fundings and net growth were concentrated in the final ten days of Q1, indicating strong underlying momentum that will flow through to interest income in Q2 and beyond. This is reinforced by the hiring of John Wilgus as SVP focused on commercial real estate lending—a critical growth lever—whose 32 years of experience in structuring financing solutions for closely held businesses and developers directly aligns with CFBK’s boutique model. The expansion of regional teams is not merely additive but transformative: it enables the bank to win high-quality relationships against larger competitors by offering individualized service and direct access to decision-makers, a structural advantage that scales efficiently without bureaucratic drag. Furthermore, the company’s disciplined approach to pricing—maintaining loan floor rates and resisting margin compression—has already begun to pay off, as evidenced by NIM expanding modestly year-over-year despite pressures from large deposit clients. With commercial loan and deposit pipelines described as “robust” and the expectation that loan payoffs will decline in subsequent quarters, the foundation is in place for accelerating core earnings power. Since the 2012 recapitalization, CFBK has achieved a 20% CAGR, and the current investments in talent and market depth position it to exceed this historical run rate as it scales its commercial franchise in underserved yet affluent Midwest markets.
CFBK’s non-interest income initiatives are emerging as a material and underappreciated driver of earnings diversification and resilience, particularly as interest rate volatility persists. In Q1 2026, non-interest income grew 23% year-over-year to $1.5 million, driven by a 26% increase in service charges on deposit accounts and strategic efforts to expand residential mortgage salable loan volumes, treasury management fees, and interest rate swap income. The hiring of Gregory Perelka as President of Residential Mortgage Lending—announced May 19, 2026—signals a serious commitment to scaling this business line, which management explicitly noted has been exited or scaled back by competitors, creating a vacuum CFBK is poised to fill. Perelka’s background in leading large teams, implementing technology solutions, and driving P&L leadership at institutions like Citizens Financial Group and NewRez LLC brings immediate operational credibility. His focus on upgrading mortgage operations, introducing new portfolio and salable loan products, and implementing cost efficiencies will directly enhance fee-based revenue streams while cross-selling opportunities with the commercial banking division increase customer lifetime value. This is not a peripheral effort: management framed residential mortgage lending as a “proven value of mortgage lending as a long-term relationship builder” that fuels broader banking relationships. With Q1 non-interest income already up 23% and the mortgage team now under seasoned leadership, the ramp in fee income is likely to accelerate, providing a buffer against NIM pressure and supporting higher-margin earnings growth. The market appears to be overlooking how these initiatives transform CFBK from a pure-play lender into a full-service relationship bank with recurring, sticky revenue streams.
CFBK’s capital efficiency and conservative risk profile offer significant upside potential that is not reflected in its current valuation, particularly as regulatory tailwinds and internal improvements compound. The bank maintains strong capital ratios, with a Tier 1 leverage ratio of 11.76% and total risk-based capital ratio of 15.15% as of Q1 2026—both well above regulatory minimums and indicative of a fortress balance sheet. This strength allows CFBK to absorb credit events without constraint, as evidenced by the relatively modest impact of placing a $5.0 million non-core commercial loan on nonaccrual status, which only reduced NIM by 11bps and resulted in minimal net charge-offs of $16,000 for the quarter. The allowance for credit losses to nonperforming loans stands at 91.77%, reflecting adequate coverage despite a rise in nonaccrual loans to 1.14% of total loans. More importantly, the bank’s efficiency ratio, while up to 56.13% in Q1 2026 due to seasonal marketing spend, remains within its long-term target range and has historically averaged below 50%, reflecting the scalability of its branch-lite model. With stockholders’ equity growing 9.4% year-over-year to $189.0 million and tangible book value per share at $28.20—above the current market price of $27.91—the stock trades at a discount to tangible book value, suggesting mispricing. The combination of organic loan growth potential, fee income expansion, and excess capital capacity creates multiple pathways for value accretion: dividend increases (already up 13% quarterly), share repurchases, or strategic acquisitions. Management’s consistent emphasis on “quality growth” and “scaling the commercial bank” implies that capital will be deployed prudently but aggressively toward accretive opportunities, a dynamic the market is failing to price in given the bank’s low-profile, Midwest-centric narrative.

CFBK's strategic focus on deepening its commercial banking teams across its five major metro markets—Columbus, Cleveland, Cincinnati, Akron, and Indianapolis—represents a high-conviction catalyst for sustained loan growth that the market is underestimating. The Q1 2026 results showed net core commercial loan growth of $45 million, translating to an annualized rate of 15%, despite timing-related headwinds from early-quarter loan payoffs. Management explicitly noted that heavier loan fundings and net growth were concentrated in the final ten days of Q1, indicating strong underlying momentum that will flow through to interest income in Q2 and beyond. This is reinforced by the hiring of John Wilgus as SVP focused on commercial real estate lending—a critical growth lever—whose 32 years of experience in structuring financing solutions for closely held businesses and developers directly aligns with CFBK’s boutique model. The expansion of regional teams is not merely additive but transformative: it enables the bank to win high-quality relationships against larger competitors by offering individualized service and direct access to decision-makers, a structural advantage that scales efficiently without bureaucratic drag. Furthermore, the company’s disciplined approach to pricing—maintaining loan floor rates and resisting margin compression—has already begun to pay off, as evidenced by NIM expanding modestly year-over-year despite pressures from large deposit clients. With commercial loan and deposit pipelines described as “robust” and the expectation that loan payoffs will decline in subsequent quarters, the foundation is in place for accelerating core earnings power. Since the 2012 recapitalization, CFBK has achieved a 20% CAGR, and the current investments in talent and market depth position it to exceed this historical run rate as it scales its commercial franchise in underserved yet affluent Midwest markets.
CFBK’s non-interest income initiatives are emerging as a material and underappreciated driver of earnings diversification and resilience, particularly as interest rate volatility persists. In Q1 2026, non-interest income grew 23% year-over-year to $1.5 million, driven by a 26% increase in service charges on deposit accounts and strategic efforts to expand residential mortgage salable loan volumes, treasury management fees, and interest rate swap income. The hiring of Gregory Perelka as President of Residential Mortgage Lending—announced May 19, 2026—signals a serious commitment to scaling this business line, which management explicitly noted has been exited or scaled back by competitors, creating a vacuum CFBK is poised to fill. Perelka’s background in leading large teams, implementing technology solutions, and driving P&L leadership at institutions like Citizens Financial Group and NewRez LLC brings immediate operational credibility. His focus on upgrading mortgage operations, introducing new portfolio and salable loan products, and implementing cost efficiencies will directly enhance fee-based revenue streams while cross-selling opportunities with the commercial banking division increase customer lifetime value. This is not a peripheral effort: management framed residential mortgage lending as a “proven value of mortgage lending as a long-term relationship builder” that fuels broader banking relationships. With Q1 non-interest income already up 23% and the mortgage team now under seasoned leadership, the ramp in fee income is likely to accelerate, providing a buffer against NIM pressure and supporting higher-margin earnings growth. The market appears to be overlooking how these initiatives transform CFBK from a pure-play lender into a full-service relationship bank with recurring, sticky revenue streams.
CFBK’s capital efficiency and conservative risk profile offer significant upside potential that is not reflected in its current valuation, particularly as regulatory tailwinds and internal improvements compound. The bank maintains strong capital ratios, with a Tier 1 leverage ratio of 11.76% and total risk-based capital ratio of 15.15% as of Q1 2026—both well above regulatory minimums and indicative of a fortress balance sheet. This strength allows CFBK to absorb credit events without constraint, as evidenced by the relatively modest impact of placing a $5.0 million non-core commercial loan on nonaccrual status, which only reduced NIM by 11bps and resulted in minimal net charge-offs of $16,000 for the quarter. The allowance for credit losses to nonperforming loans stands at 91.77%, reflecting adequate coverage despite a rise in nonaccrual loans to 1.14% of total loans. More importantly, the bank’s efficiency ratio, while up to 56.13% in Q1 2026 due to seasonal marketing spend, remains within its long-term target range and has historically averaged below 50%, reflecting the scalability of its branch-lite model. With stockholders’ equity growing 9.4% year-over-year to $189.0 million and tangible book value per share at $28.20—above the current market price of $27.91—the stock trades at a discount to tangible book value, suggesting mispricing. The combination of organic loan growth potential, fee income expansion, and excess capital capacity creates multiple pathways for value accretion: dividend increases (already up 13% quarterly), share repurchases, or strategic acquisitions. Management’s consistent emphasis on “quality growth” and “scaling the commercial bank” implies that capital will be deployed prudently but aggressively toward accretive opportunities, a dynamic the market is failing to price in given the bank’s low-profile, Midwest-centric narrative.

▼ Bear case

CFBK’s asset quality deterioration, particularly the sharp rise in nonaccrual loans, signals emerging credit risks that management is downplaying as isolated or non-core, but which could indicate broader underwriting stress in its commercial portfolio. Nonaccrual loans increased to $20.3 million (1.14% of total loans) at March 31, 2026, up from $15.3 million (0.87%) at December 31, 2025 and $14.5 million (0.82%) a year earlier—a 40% quarter-over-quarter increase driven largely by the addition of a single $5.0 million non-core commercial and industrial loan. While management characterized this loan as “non-core (non-customer)” and noted that $5.1 million of the total nonaccrual balance is SBA-guaranteed, the rapid accumulation of problem loans in just one quarter raises concerns about the effectiveness of its risk monitoring, especially given its stated focus on closely held businesses and entrepreneurs. The increase in loans 30 days or more past due to $17.5 million (from $12.9 million prior quarter and $11.4 million year-over-year) further underscores weakening payment trends, with the same $5.0 million non-core loan cited as the primary driver. Although net charge-offs remained low at $16,000 due to the non-accrual status preventing immediate realization of losses, the trend in delinquencies and nonaccruals suggests potential for future provisioning pressure if similar credits deteriorate. The bank’s reliance on SBA guarantees to mitigate risk may also create moral hazard or mask underlying credit weakness, as these guarantees do not eliminate performance risk—only loss severity. With commercial real estate and C&I lending representing the core of its growth strategy, any broadening of credit issues beyond isolated non-core loans could quickly erode profitability, especially given the modest allowance coverage of 1.05% of total loans. The market may be underestimating the sensitivity of CFBK’s niche commercial model to economic headwinds, particularly if Ohio and Indiana markets experience slower-than-expected recovery or sector-specific stress in areas like office or retail CRE, where balances remain sizable ($39.5 million and $117.5 million, respectively, as of Q1 2026).
CFBK’s deposit base remains vulnerable to competitive pricing pressures and behavioral shifts that could undermine its funding advantage and compress net interest margin, despite management’s optimism about stabilizing rates. As of Q1 2026, 29.8% of deposit balances exceeded the FDIC insurance limit of $250,000—a level that has remained persistently high (29.5% at Dec 2025, 31.1% at Mar 2025)—indicating a significant portion of deposits are rate-sensitive and prone to migration if competitors offer better yields. While interest-bearing deposits grew 1.6% quarter-over-quarter to $1.57 billion, this was driven by a $73.7 million increase in interest-bearing accounts, partially offset by a $44.9 million decline in noninterest-bearing balances, suggesting customers are shifting toward yield-seeking products. The bank’s average rate paid on interest-bearing liabilities decreased only 27bps versus the prior quarter and 50bps year-over-year, implying limited success in lowering funding costs despite management’s claims of “maintaining strong pricing disciplines.” More concerning, the net interest margin of 2.69% in Q1 2026 decreased 16bps sequentially and increased just 5bps year-over-year, reflecting persistent pressure from both asset-side yield compression (average yield on interest-earning assets down 30-31bps vs. prior periods) and incomplete liability-side repricing benefit. Management acknowledged that NIM expansion was hampered by “overcoming pressures from large Deposit Clients to receive greater Interest Income,” indicating that key wholesale or municipal depositors—identified as a funding source for residential mortgages—are successfully negotiating better terms. If the Federal Reserve maintains higher rates for longer or if regional banks intensify competition for municipal and corporate deposits, CFBK may be forced to accept higher funding costs or lose valuable relationships, directly impacting its core profitability. The business model’s reliance on attracting and retaining these large, sophisticated depositors without matching their rate expectations represents a structural vulnerability that growth in loans alone cannot offset.
CFBK’s operating leverage is constrained by rising noninterest expenses that are growing faster than revenue, calling into question the scalability of its boutique model and the effectiveness of its cost controls, particularly as it invests in talent and marketing. Noninterest expense increased 7.4% quarter-over-quarter to $8.3 million in Q1 2026, driven by a $545,000 rise in salaries and employee benefits—attributed to higher payroll tax and 401(k) match expenses in the first quarter—and a surge in advertising and promotion costs, which were “roughly double what we would expect going forward” due to testing additional marketing campaigns. While some of this increase is seasonal or experimental, the year-over-year rise of 4.5% in noninterest expense (to $8.3 million from $8.0 million in Q1 2025) suggests a trend of rising fixed costs as the bank expands its teams and market presence. This is particularly concerning given that net interest income grew only 3.2% year-over-year to $13.3 million, and noninterest income rose 23.3% but from a relatively small base ($1.2 million to $1.5 million). The efficiency ratio worsened to 56.13% in Q1 2026 from 49.17% in Q4 2025 and 55.94% in Q1 2025, indicating that the bank is not yet achieving the operating leverage implied by its “branch lite” model. Management’s own commentary noted that advertising costs were elevated due to testing, implying that these expenses may not normalize quickly if new campaigns prove effective and are retained. Furthermore, the hiring of high-profile executives like John Wilgus and Gregory Perelka—while strategically sound—comes with significant salary and incentive costs that will persist regardless of short-term revenue outcomes. If loan growth and fee income expansion fail to keep pace with these rising operating costs, profitability could stagnate or decline, undermining the investment thesis. The market may be assuming that scale will naturally bring efficiency, but CFBK’s current trajectory shows expenses rising in tandem with, or ahead of, revenue growth, suggesting that its differentiator—personalized service and direct access—may be inherently costly to maintain at scale.

CFBK’s asset quality deterioration, particularly the sharp rise in nonaccrual loans, signals emerging credit risks that management is downplaying as isolated or non-core, but which could indicate broader underwriting stress in its commercial portfolio. Nonaccrual loans increased to $20.3 million (1.14% of total loans) at March 31, 2026, up from $15.3 million (0.87%) at December 31, 2025 and $14.5 million (0.82%) a year earlier—a 40% quarter-over-quarter increase driven largely by the addition of a single $5.0 million non-core commercial and industrial loan. While management characterized this loan as “non-core (non-customer)” and noted that $5.1 million of the total nonaccrual balance is SBA-guaranteed, the rapid accumulation of problem loans in just one quarter raises concerns about the effectiveness of its risk monitoring, especially given its stated focus on closely held businesses and entrepreneurs. The increase in loans 30 days or more past due to $17.5 million (from $12.9 million prior quarter and $11.4 million year-over-year) further underscores weakening payment trends, with the same $5.0 million non-core loan cited as the primary driver. Although net charge-offs remained low at $16,000 due to the non-accrual status preventing immediate realization of losses, the trend in delinquencies and nonaccruals suggests potential for future provisioning pressure if similar credits deteriorate. The bank’s reliance on SBA guarantees to mitigate risk may also create moral hazard or mask underlying credit weakness, as these guarantees do not eliminate performance risk—only loss severity. With commercial real estate and C&I lending representing the core of its growth strategy, any broadening of credit issues beyond isolated non-core loans could quickly erode profitability, especially given the modest allowance coverage of 1.05% of total loans. The market may be underestimating the sensitivity of CFBK’s niche commercial model to economic headwinds, particularly if Ohio and Indiana markets experience slower-than-expected recovery or sector-specific stress in areas like office or retail CRE, where balances remain sizable ($39.5 million and $117.5 million, respectively, as of Q1 2026).
CFBK’s deposit base remains vulnerable to competitive pricing pressures and behavioral shifts that could undermine its funding advantage and compress net interest margin, despite management’s optimism about stabilizing rates. As of Q1 2026, 29.8% of deposit balances exceeded the FDIC insurance limit of $250,000—a level that has remained persistently high (29.5% at Dec 2025, 31.1% at Mar 2025)—indicating a significant portion of deposits are rate-sensitive and prone to migration if competitors offer better yields. While interest-bearing deposits grew 1.6% quarter-over-quarter to $1.57 billion, this was driven by a $73.7 million increase in interest-bearing accounts, partially offset by a $44.9 million decline in noninterest-bearing balances, suggesting customers are shifting toward yield-seeking products. The bank’s average rate paid on interest-bearing liabilities decreased only 27bps versus the prior quarter and 50bps year-over-year, implying limited success in lowering funding costs despite management’s claims of “maintaining strong pricing disciplines.” More concerning, the net interest margin of 2.69% in Q1 2026 decreased 16bps sequentially and increased just 5bps year-over-year, reflecting persistent pressure from both asset-side yield compression (average yield on interest-earning assets down 30-31bps vs. prior periods) and incomplete liability-side repricing benefit. Management acknowledged that NIM expansion was hampered by “overcoming pressures from large Deposit Clients to receive greater Interest Income,” indicating that key wholesale or municipal depositors—identified as a funding source for residential mortgages—are successfully negotiating better terms. If the Federal Reserve maintains higher rates for longer or if regional banks intensify competition for municipal and corporate deposits, CFBK may be forced to accept higher funding costs or lose valuable relationships, directly impacting its core profitability. The business model’s reliance on attracting and retaining these large, sophisticated depositors without matching their rate expectations represents a structural vulnerability that growth in loans alone cannot offset.
CFBK’s operating leverage is constrained by rising noninterest expenses that are growing faster than revenue, calling into question the scalability of its boutique model and the effectiveness of its cost controls, particularly as it invests in talent and marketing. Noninterest expense increased 7.4% quarter-over-quarter to $8.3 million in Q1 2026, driven by a $545,000 rise in salaries and employee benefits—attributed to higher payroll tax and 401(k) match expenses in the first quarter—and a surge in advertising and promotion costs, which were “roughly double what we would expect going forward” due to testing additional marketing campaigns. While some of this increase is seasonal or experimental, the year-over-year rise of 4.5% in noninterest expense (to $8.3 million from $8.0 million in Q1 2025) suggests a trend of rising fixed costs as the bank expands its teams and market presence. This is particularly concerning given that net interest income grew only 3.2% year-over-year to $13.3 million, and noninterest income rose 23.3% but from a relatively small base ($1.2 million to $1.5 million). The efficiency ratio worsened to 56.13% in Q1 2026 from 49.17% in Q4 2025 and 55.94% in Q1 2025, indicating that the bank is not yet achieving the operating leverage implied by its “branch lite” model. Management’s own commentary noted that advertising costs were elevated due to testing, implying that these expenses may not normalize quickly if new campaigns prove effective and are retained. Furthermore, the hiring of high-profile executives like John Wilgus and Gregory Perelka—while strategically sound—comes with significant salary and incentive costs that will persist regardless of short-term revenue outcomes. If loan growth and fee income expansion fail to keep pace with these rising operating costs, profitability could stagnate or decline, undermining the investment thesis. The market may be assuming that scale will naturally bring efficiency, but CFBK’s current trajectory shows expenses rising in tandem with, or ahead of, revenue growth, suggesting that its differentiator—personalized service and direct access—may be inherently costly to maintain at scale.

Peer Comparison

Companies in the Banks - Regional

S.No.	Ticker	Company	Market Cap	P/E	P/S	Total Debt (Qtr)
1	KB	KB Financial Group Inc.	42,090.38 Bn	0.00 Bn	0.01 Mn	56.66 Bn
2	SHG	Shinhan Financial Group Co Ltd	33,919.15 Bn	0.00 Bn	0.00 Mn	40.46 Bn
3	BCH	Bank Of Chile	4,123.52 Bn	368.17 Bn	1.57 Mn	0.00 Bn
4	LYG	Lloyds Banking Group plc	360.83 Bn	0.00 Bn	0.00 Mn	42.37 Bn
5	FCAP	First Capital Inc	204.17 Bn	0.00 Bn	0.03 Mn	-
6	LARK	Landmark Bancorp Inc	187.97 Bn	0.00 Bn	0.00 Mn	0.00 Bn
7	NWG	NatWest Group plc	144.82 Bn	0.00 Bn	0.00 Mn	94.66 Bn
8	PNC	Pnc Financial Services Group, Inc.	101.80 Bn	0.00 Bn	0.00 Mn	21.42 Bn

Research Tools

Developers

About

Investment Thesis

Peer Comparison

Research Tools

Developers

About

Investment Thesis

Peer Comparison

Create an account

Sign In

Reset Password