Alico, Inc. (ALCO) Stock Analysis and Metrics

Alico

NASDAQ: ALCO

$38.64 ▼ -0.48 (-1.23%)

At close: Jul 24, 2026 · 3:59 PM UTC

Financial Ratios

Market Cap298.33 Mn

P/E-15.59

P/S18.17

Div. Yield0.01

ROIC (Qtr)-0.14

Total Debt (Qtr)82.96 Mn

Revenue Growth (1y) (Qtr)-70.30

Add ratio to table…

About

Alico, Inc. operates as an agriculture and land management company primarily engaged in the production and sale of citrus products, the leasing of its citrus groves for farming, grazing and hunting activities, and the generation of income from rock and sand mining royalties, sod sales, and oil extraction rights leases. The company also engages in miscellaneous operations that support its diversified land usage and real estate development strategy. The company controls approximately 40,428 gross acres of land, which it uses for citrus cultivation, leasing, mining royalties, and real estate development. It conducts all of its operations within the United States.

Revenue is generated mainly from the sale of fresh and processed citrus fruit to juice processors and packing houses, lease payments from farming, grazing and hunting agreements, royalties from rock and sand mining operators, proceeds from sod sales, and fees from leasing oil extraction rights to third parties. Additional income comes from other miscellaneous land related activities. The company’s customer base includes citrus processors, packing houses, agricultural lessees, mining firms, and various third party lessees. In recent periods, the company has also generated significant cash from the sale of land parcels, supplementing its recurring operating revenue.

The company operates through the following segments: Alico Citrus and Land Management and Other Operations.

• Alico Citrus: This segment includes planting, owning, cultivating and managing citrus groves to produce fruit for sale to fresh and processed markets, as well as the purchase and resale of fruit and value added services such as contracting for harvesting, marketing and hauling of citrus.

• Land Management and Other Operations: This segment covers leasing of citrus groves, farming, grazing and hunting leases, management and conservation of native pastureland, rock mining royalties, sod sales, and ownership or leasing of improved farmland with irrigation, drainage and road improvements.

Within the Florida agricultural sector, Alico, Inc. holds a notable position as one of the larger private owners of citrus grove land, competing with other regional growers and large integrated citrus processors. Its competitive advantages stem from extensive land holdings, a diversified revenue mix that reduces reliance on any single commodity, and a long term strategy focused on real estate development and sustainable land use.

The company serves citrus processors such as Tropicana, packing houses that purchase fruit on a per box basis, and agricultural lessees who pay for farming, grazing and hunting rights. It also receives royalties from rock and sand mining companies and revenue from sod purchasers and oil rights lessees.

Investment Thesis

▲ Bull case

Alico's strategic land monetization through the January sale of 2,950 acres for $26.9 million, generating a $19.8 million gain, demonstrates the tangible value embedded in its Florida portfolio, with proceeds significantly boosting cash reserves to $52.9 million and extending the financial runway through fiscal 2028 without reliance on external financing, providing management the flexibility to pursue development initiatives on their own timeline rather than under liquidity pressure, which is a critical advantage in a capital-intensive real estate development environment where timing and control over execution can substantially impact project returns and shareholder value creation.
The unanimous Collier County Board of Commissioners approval for Corkscrew Grove East Village, authorizing up to 4,502 dwelling units on 1,446 acres including affordable housing and neighborhood retail, represents a de-risked regulatory milestone that substantially reduces entitlement uncertainty, with management explicitly targeting state approval by early 2027 and federal approval by end of 2028, positioning the project for potential construction commencement in 2028 or 2029, and this progression through key permitting stages—despite not being heavily promoted in prepared remarks—signals advancing momentum toward monetization of what management estimates as a $335 million to $380 million present value opportunity from just 5,500 acres across its development pipeline, implying substantial upside from the remaining 46,000 acres if similar value per acre is realized.
Alico's diversified land utilization strategy, now generating revenue from approximately 97% of its 32,500 farmable acres through agricultural partnerships with citrus growers, cattle ranchers, sugarcane producers, and sod farming operations, has transformed the business model from a capital-intensive citrus operation to a low-maintenance, cash-generating platform, with land management and other operations revenue increasing 113% year-over-year in Q2 FY26 and 97% for the six-month period, directly offsetting the wind-down of legacy citrus operations and providing a stable, growing base of operating cash flow that funds development efforts and shareholder returns without dilutive financing or asset sales at distressed values, thereby creating a resilient financial foundation that supports long-term value creation.
The market appears to be underestimating the optionality embedded in Alico's development approach for Corkscrew Grove East Village, where management retains the flexibility to sell entitled land to national or local homebuilders, partner with developers for phased returns and shared upside, or develop in-house using internal capabilities—a strategic triad that allows the company to adapt to market conditions, construction expertise gaps, and capital availability, with the CEO noting an impending decision within the next year as approval timelines shrink, suggesting that the eventual monetization path could be optimized to maximize shareholder value based on evolving real estate dynamics rather than being locked into a single, potentially suboptimal strategy.
With a current net debt of $32.6 million and $92.5 million of available borrowing capacity under its credit facility, Alico's balance sheet provides substantial financial flexibility to fund entitlement costs, infrastructure investments, and potential joint venture equity without jeopardizing liquidity, especially given the company's updated year-end cash guidance of approximately $40 million and net debt guidance of $45 million, which reflects disciplined capital allocation following the $10 million share repurchase through April 2026, indicating that the market may not be fully pricing in the company's ability to self-fund its development pipeline through operating cash flow from diversified land leases while maintaining investment-grade financial metrics.

Alico's strategic land monetization through the January sale of 2,950 acres for $26.9 million, generating a $19.8 million gain, demonstrates the tangible value embedded in its Florida portfolio, with proceeds significantly boosting cash reserves to $52.9 million and extending the financial runway through fiscal 2028 without reliance on external financing, providing management the flexibility to pursue development initiatives on their own timeline rather than under liquidity pressure, which is a critical advantage in a capital-intensive real estate development environment where timing and control over execution can substantially impact project returns and shareholder value creation.
The unanimous Collier County Board of Commissioners approval for Corkscrew Grove East Village, authorizing up to 4,502 dwelling units on 1,446 acres including affordable housing and neighborhood retail, represents a de-risked regulatory milestone that substantially reduces entitlement uncertainty, with management explicitly targeting state approval by early 2027 and federal approval by end of 2028, positioning the project for potential construction commencement in 2028 or 2029, and this progression through key permitting stages—despite not being heavily promoted in prepared remarks—signals advancing momentum toward monetization of what management estimates as a $335 million to $380 million present value opportunity from just 5,500 acres across its development pipeline, implying substantial upside from the remaining 46,000 acres if similar value per acre is realized.
Alico's diversified land utilization strategy, now generating revenue from approximately 97% of its 32,500 farmable acres through agricultural partnerships with citrus growers, cattle ranchers, sugarcane producers, and sod farming operations, has transformed the business model from a capital-intensive citrus operation to a low-maintenance, cash-generating platform, with land management and other operations revenue increasing 113% year-over-year in Q2 FY26 and 97% for the six-month period, directly offsetting the wind-down of legacy citrus operations and providing a stable, growing base of operating cash flow that funds development efforts and shareholder returns without dilutive financing or asset sales at distressed values, thereby creating a resilient financial foundation that supports long-term value creation.
The market appears to be underestimating the optionality embedded in Alico's development approach for Corkscrew Grove East Village, where management retains the flexibility to sell entitled land to national or local homebuilders, partner with developers for phased returns and shared upside, or develop in-house using internal capabilities—a strategic triad that allows the company to adapt to market conditions, construction expertise gaps, and capital availability, with the CEO noting an impending decision within the next year as approval timelines shrink, suggesting that the eventual monetization path could be optimized to maximize shareholder value based on evolving real estate dynamics rather than being locked into a single, potentially suboptimal strategy.
With a current net debt of $32.6 million and $92.5 million of available borrowing capacity under its credit facility, Alico's balance sheet provides substantial financial flexibility to fund entitlement costs, infrastructure investments, and potential joint venture equity without jeopardizing liquidity, especially given the company's updated year-end cash guidance of approximately $40 million and net debt guidance of $45 million, which reflects disciplined capital allocation following the $10 million share repurchase through April 2026, indicating that the market may not be fully pricing in the company's ability to self-fund its development pipeline through operating cash flow from diversified land leases while maintaining investment-grade financial metrics.

▼ Bear case

Alico's heavy reliance on entitlement approvals for value realization in its Corkscrew Grove East Village project exposes it to significant regulatory execution risk, as the company remains dependent on securing state approval by early 2027 and federal approval by end of 2028—a timeline that assumes smooth coordination with the South Florida Water Management District, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, with no guarantee that environmental review processes, potential third-party challenges, or shifting regulatory priorities will not delay or alter the project scope, particularly given the project's commitment to placing nearly 5,000 acres into permanent conservation, which could invite scrutiny over mitigation adequacy or trigger additional requirements that increase costs or delay timelines beyond the current 2028–2029 construction commencement window.
Despite promoting a diversified land utilization strategy, Alico's revenue transformation remains incomplete and vulnerable, as the Q2 FY26 total revenue of $5.3 million represents a 71% decline from $18 million in the prior year period, and the six-month revenue of $7.2 million is down 79% from $34.9 million, indicating that while land management and other operations revenue grew 113% and 97% respectively, this growth is occurring from a depressed base following the wind-down of citrus operations, and the company has not disclosed the sustainability or margin profile of its agricultural lease revenues, leaving open the risk that these streams may not generate sufficient or predictable cash flow to sustain operations and fund development over the multi-year entitlement process if commodity prices fluctuate or lessee demand weakens in key segments like sod farming or rock and sand royalties.
The company's share repurchase program, which deployed $10 million to acquire 245,399 shares through April 2026, may be prematurely consuming capital that could be better reserved for entitlement costs, infrastructure investments, or potential joint venture funding for Corkscrew Grove East Village, especially given that management admitted they will need to commit to a development path—whether selling entitled land, partnering with builders, or developing in-house—within the next year as approval timelines shrink, and with net debt already at $32.6 million and a stated goal to end the fiscal year with only the minimum $2.5 million on the revolving line of credit, Alico risks overextending its balance sheet if entitlement delays necessitate unplanned funding or if development-phase capital calls arise before monetization is achieved.
Alico's management-guided net present value range of $650 million to $750 million for its remaining 46,000 acres appears to rely on conservative agricultural-use assumptions ($4,000–$5,000 per acre) that may not reflect the full spectrum of land heterogeneity, as the CEO acknowledged that recent land trades have occurred in the $9,000 per acre range and that some parcels—particularly those with development potential like Corkscrew Grove, Bonnett Lake, or Saddlebag Grove—likely command significantly higher values, yet the company has not provided a granular breakdown of its portfolio by use case, leaving investors unable to verify whether the implied valuation multiple is justified or whether the market is already pricing in a portion of the development upside, thereby creating ambiguity around true intrinsic value and increasing the risk of overestimation if entitlement delays or approval setbacks reduce the likelihood of realizing higher-value outcomes.
The company's repeated emphasis on its "balanced portfolio approach" with 75% of land continuing in agricultural use may obscure a strategic misalignment, as the pursuit of high-value entitled development projects like Corkscrew Grove East Village—targeting up to 4,502 dwelling units and 238,000 square feet of commercial space—necessarily conflicts with long-term agricultural preservation, and the lack of clarity on how much of the 46,000 acres is truly available for sale versus encumbered by conservation commitments, leases, or environmental restrictions raises concerns that the usable developable land base is smaller than implied, potentially limiting the scale of value creation and forcing Alico to accept lower returns or prolonged timelines to achieve its stated NPV targets, especially if conservation obligations tied to project approvals reduce the net acreage available for profitable development.

Alico's heavy reliance on entitlement approvals for value realization in its Corkscrew Grove East Village project exposes it to significant regulatory execution risk, as the company remains dependent on securing state approval by early 2027 and federal approval by end of 2028—a timeline that assumes smooth coordination with the South Florida Water Management District, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, with no guarantee that environmental review processes, potential third-party challenges, or shifting regulatory priorities will not delay or alter the project scope, particularly given the project's commitment to placing nearly 5,000 acres into permanent conservation, which could invite scrutiny over mitigation adequacy or trigger additional requirements that increase costs or delay timelines beyond the current 2028–2029 construction commencement window.
Despite promoting a diversified land utilization strategy, Alico's revenue transformation remains incomplete and vulnerable, as the Q2 FY26 total revenue of $5.3 million represents a 71% decline from $18 million in the prior year period, and the six-month revenue of $7.2 million is down 79% from $34.9 million, indicating that while land management and other operations revenue grew 113% and 97% respectively, this growth is occurring from a depressed base following the wind-down of citrus operations, and the company has not disclosed the sustainability or margin profile of its agricultural lease revenues, leaving open the risk that these streams may not generate sufficient or predictable cash flow to sustain operations and fund development over the multi-year entitlement process if commodity prices fluctuate or lessee demand weakens in key segments like sod farming or rock and sand royalties.
The company's share repurchase program, which deployed $10 million to acquire 245,399 shares through April 2026, may be prematurely consuming capital that could be better reserved for entitlement costs, infrastructure investments, or potential joint venture funding for Corkscrew Grove East Village, especially given that management admitted they will need to commit to a development path—whether selling entitled land, partnering with builders, or developing in-house—within the next year as approval timelines shrink, and with net debt already at $32.6 million and a stated goal to end the fiscal year with only the minimum $2.5 million on the revolving line of credit, Alico risks overextending its balance sheet if entitlement delays necessitate unplanned funding or if development-phase capital calls arise before monetization is achieved.
Alico's management-guided net present value range of $650 million to $750 million for its remaining 46,000 acres appears to rely on conservative agricultural-use assumptions ($4,000–$5,000 per acre) that may not reflect the full spectrum of land heterogeneity, as the CEO acknowledged that recent land trades have occurred in the $9,000 per acre range and that some parcels—particularly those with development potential like Corkscrew Grove, Bonnett Lake, or Saddlebag Grove—likely command significantly higher values, yet the company has not provided a granular breakdown of its portfolio by use case, leaving investors unable to verify whether the implied valuation multiple is justified or whether the market is already pricing in a portion of the development upside, thereby creating ambiguity around true intrinsic value and increasing the risk of overestimation if entitlement delays or approval setbacks reduce the likelihood of realizing higher-value outcomes.
The company's repeated emphasis on its "balanced portfolio approach" with 75% of land continuing in agricultural use may obscure a strategic misalignment, as the pursuit of high-value entitled development projects like Corkscrew Grove East Village—targeting up to 4,502 dwelling units and 238,000 square feet of commercial space—necessarily conflicts with long-term agricultural preservation, and the lack of clarity on how much of the 46,000 acres is truly available for sale versus encumbered by conservation commitments, leases, or environmental restrictions raises concerns that the usable developable land base is smaller than implied, potentially limiting the scale of value creation and forcing Alico to accept lower returns or prolonged timelines to achieve its stated NPV targets, especially if conservation obligations tied to project approvals reduce the net acreage available for profitable development.

Segments Breakdown of Revenue (2025)

Peer Comparison

Companies in the Farm Products

S.No.	Ticker	Company	Market Cap	P/E	P/S	Total Debt (Qtr)
1	ADM	Archer-Daniels-Midland Co	41.79 Bn	38.55	0.52	8.22 Bn
2	BG	Bunge Global SA	23.70 Bn	329.16	0.29	12.67 Bn
3	CALM	Cal-Maine Foods Inc	4.20 Bn	13.20	1.44	-
4	DMC	Del Monte Corp	1.35 Bn	18.61	0.32	0.46 Bn
5	DOLE	Dole plc	1.34 Bn	-29.05	0.14	0.91 Bn
6	AGRO	Adecoagro S.A.	1.10 Bn	24.33	0.77	1.52 Bn
7	VITL	Vital Farms, Inc.	0.57 Bn	7.92	0.72	-
8	ALCO	Alico, Inc.	0.30 Bn	-15.59	18.17	0.08 Bn

Research Tools

Developers

About

Investment Thesis

Segments Breakdown of Revenue (2025)

Segments Breakdown of Revenue (2025)

Peer Comparison

Research Tools

Developers

About

Investment Thesis

Segments Breakdown of Revenue (2025)

Segments Breakdown of Revenue (2025)

Peer Comparison

Create an account

Sign In

Reset Password