CLF vs MSB vs SID Stock Comparison

Cleveland-Cliffs, Mesabi Trust and National Steel Prices as of Nov 16, 2026 Peers: Industry group
1 more company in this comparison (CMC) Create a free account to keep reading and compare up to 10 companies.
CLF Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.
$12.10 -0.4% 1M +12.8% 1Y
Market cap
$6.76B
P/E
–
Revenue (TTM)
$20.07B
Div. yield
–
Steel Basic Materials
2 wins
MSB Mesabi Trust
$15.89 -11.1% 1M -54.4% 1Y
Market cap
$209.40M
P/E
32.3x
Revenue (TTM)
$11.91M
Div. yield
-0.06%
Iron Ore Basic Materials
4 wins
SID National Steel Co
$0.62 -44.1% 1M -61.5% 1Y
Market cap
$832.92M
P/E
–
Revenue (TTM)
$18.30B
Div. yield
–
Steel Basic Materials
2 wins

Head to Head

8 decided of 12

Mesabi Trust leads on 4 of the 12 questions below (Mesabi Trust 4, Cleveland-Cliffs 2, National Steel 2). Which ones matter depends on what you are buying for; a cheap multiple and slow growth often come together.

QuestionCLFMSBSIDLeader
Larger companyMarket capitalisation $6.76B $209.40M $832.92M CLF
Cheaper on earningsLower P/E, profitable companies only -14.3x 32.3x -2.5x –
Cheaper on forward earningsLower price / next fiscal year consensus EPS 210.8x — — –
Faster revenue growthRevenue growth, trailing twelve months +7.8% -87.6% +23.4% SID
More profitableNet margin, trailing twelve months -2.4% 54.5% -1.8% MSB
Better return on capitalReturn on invested capital -1.3% — — –
Less leveragedLower net debt / EBITDA 9.8x — -1.0x SID
Higher dividend yieldTrailing dividend yield 0.00% -0.06% 0.00% –
Better 1-year returnPrice return, last 12 months +12.8% -54.4% -61.5% CLF
Better 5-year returnAnnualised price return, 5 years -10.8%/yr -8.2%/yr -30.4%/yr MSB
Less volatileAnnualised volatility, 1 year 66.9% 45.9% 75.2% MSB
Higher overall scoreMean of the five percentile scores vs peers 39/100 58/100 34/100 MSB

Percentile Scorecard

CLFMSBSID

Each axis is the mean percentile of its metrics against the company's industry group. 100 is the best in the group, 50 the middle.

Scores by Axis

AxisCLFMSBSID
Valuation 67 #58 of 175 58 #74 of 175 21 #138 of 175
Growth 38 #99 of 158 23 #122 of 158 18 #130 of 158
Profitability 39 #82 of 134 94 #9 of 134 42 #78 of 134
Financial Health 11 #157 of 177 – 78 #39 of 177
Shareholder Returns – 58 #51 of 120 11 #107 of 120
Overall 39 58 34
  • CLF ranked among 184 companies in Metals and Mining
  • MSB ranked among 184 companies in Metals and Mining
  • SID ranked among 184 companies in Metals and Mining

Price Performance

Price return, split-adjusted, before dividends. Click a name to hide or show it.

Returns

PeriodCLFMSBSIDSPY
1 month -0.4%-11.1%-44.1% -3.0%
3 months -1.7%-32.0%-31.1% -4.2%
6 months +13.5%-44.2%-50.4% +0.2%
Year to date -8.9%-58.7%-61.3% +8.5%
1 year +12.8%-54.4%-61.5% +10.1%
3 years -28.8%-15.9%-79.3% +64.1%
3 years, per year -10.7%-5.6%-40.9% +18.0%
5 years -43.5%-34.6%-83.7% +58.1%
5 years, per year -10.8%-8.2%-30.4% +9.6%
10 years +61.5%+52.8%-79.7% +239.6%
10 years, per year +4.9%+4.3%-14.7% +13.0%

Risk

MeasureCLFMSBSIDSPY
Volatility, 1Y 66.9%45.9%75.2% 13.8%
Downside volatility, 1Y 70.5%50.2%87.0% 14.2%
Beta vs S&P 500, 1Y 1.990.751.83 1.00
Return / volatility, 1Y 0.19-1.19-0.82 0.74
Max drawdown, 5Y -82.4%-61.4%-89.1% -25.4%
From 52-week high -19.8%-61.4%-70.8% -5.0%
52-week high $15.09$41.15$2.12 $779.14
52-week low $7.82$15.89$0.62 $631.97

Valuation History

Weekly multiples on trailing twelve-month fundamentals. Negative or extreme readings (a loss year, a collapsed denominator) are left out so the chart stays readable.

MultipleCLFMSBSID
P/E now vs peer median -15.3xmedian 13.1x 32.8xmedian 13.1x -2.5xmedian 13.1x
P/S now vs peer median 0.4xmedian 2.7x 17.9xmedian 2.7x 0.0xmedian 2.7x
EV/EBITDA now vs peer median 19.2xmedian 7.5x —median 7.5x -0.6xmedian 7.5x
P/FCF now vs peer median -14.9xmedian 11.7x 24.4xmedian 11.7x -1.1xmedian 11.7x
P/B now vs peer median 1.2xmedian 2.1x —median 2.1x —median 2.1x
PEG now vs peer median 0.32median 0.16 -22.57median 0.16 0.06median 0.16

Financial History

Reported figures by fiscal period, placed on the calendar year (or quarter) each period ended in, so companies with different fiscal years line up.

Trailing twelve monthsCLFMSBSID
Revenue $20.07B $11.91M $18.30B
Gross profit $309.00M $6.49M $2.18B
Operating income -$282.00M $3.08M $813.51M
Net income -$460.00M $6.49M -$703.42M
Free cash flow -$485.00M $8.73M -$794.46M
EPS (diluted) $-0.82 $0.49 $-2.04
Cash & equivalents $77.00M $17.39M $2.63B
Total debt $7.65B – $362.23M
Shares (diluted) 574.00M 13.12M 161.19M
Enterprise value $6.51B $125.37M -$5.14B

All Metrics

58 metrics · best in bold

Bold marks the best reading: the lowest positive value for multiples, leverage and payout, the highest for everything else. The bar under each value is its percentile against that company's own peers. Hover a value for its rank and the peer median.

Valuation

12 metrics
MetricCLFMSBSID
P/E -15.3x 32.8x -2.5x
P/FCF -14.9x 24.4x -1.1x
P/Operating cash flow 62.2x 24.4x -1.1x
P/S 0.4x 17.9x 0.0x
P/B 1.2x – –
P/Tangible book 1.5x – –
EV/EBITDA 19.2x – -0.6x
EV/EBIT -52.4x 63.4x -1.9x
EV/Revenue 0.7x 16.4x -0.1x
EV/FCF -30.5x 22.4x 2.0x
EV/Operating cash flow 127.5x 22.4x 2.0x
PEG (3Y EPS CAGR) 0.32 -22.57 0.06

Growth

14 metrics
MetricCLFMSBSID
Revenue growth (1Y) 7.8% -87.6% 23.4%
Revenue CAGR (3Y) -2.9% -5.2% 18.9%
Gross profit growth (1Y) 133.3% -93.0% 9.8%
Gross profit CAGR (3Y) -35.7% -16.5% -20.1%
Operating income growth (1Y) 83.5% -96.5% -8.9%
Operating income CAGR (3Y) -35.2% -28.0% -24.9%
Net income growth (1Y) 72.7% -93.0% 13.4%
Net income CAGR (3Y) -48.0% -1.5% -11.8%
EPS growth (1Y) 75.7% -93.0% 15.4%
EPS CAGR (3Y) -47.9% -1.5% -42.2%
Operating cash flow growth (1Y) 112.6% -90.7% -200.4%
Operating cash flow CAGR (3Y) -61.9% 43.1% -65.5%
Free cash flow growth (1Y) 68.6% -90.7% -200.4%
Free cash flow CAGR (3Y) -32.9% 43.1% -65.5%

Profitability

14 metrics
MetricCLFMSBSID
Gross margin 1.5% 54.5% 11.9%
EBITDA margin 3.8% – 13.2%
Operating margin -1.4% 25.9% 4.4%
Pretax margin -3.4% 31.9% -3.2%
Net margin -2.4% 54.5% -1.8%
FCF margin -2.4% 73.3% -4.3%
Operating cash flow margin 0.6% 73.3% -4.3%
Return on equity -7.3% – –
Return on assets -2.1% 18.2% -8.4%
Return on invested capital -1.3% – –
Return on capital employed -1.7% – –
Asset turnover 1.0x 0.6x 1.8x
Cash conversion (OCF / net income) -0.3x 1.3x 1.1x
Stock comp / revenue – – –

Financial Health

11 metrics
MetricCLFMSBSID
Debt / assets 37.6% – 1.9%
Debt / equity 1.3x – –
Net debt / EBITDA 9.8x – -1.0x
Debt / FCF -15.8x – -0.5x
Liabilities / assets 70.7% 11.4% –
Equity / assets 29.3% – –
Interest coverage – – 0.5x
Current ratio 1.9x – –
Quick ratio 0.6x – –
Cash ratio 0.0x – –
Altman Z-score 1.39 – –

Shareholder Returns

7 metrics
MetricCLFMSBSID
Dividend yield – 3.4% –
Net buyback yield – – -24.6%
Shareholder yield 0.0% 3.4% -24.6%
Payout ratio (earnings) – 194.2% –
Payout ratio (FCF) – 144.3% –
Dividend growth (1Y) – 86.7% –
Dividend CAGR (3Y) – – –

Analyst Estimates

Solid lines are reported fiscal-year results; dashed lines are the consensus for the years ahead. Hover a year for the analysts' high and low, and how each result compared with its estimate.

ConsensusCLFMSBSID
Forward P/E 210.8xFY2026 – –
EPS, next fiscal year $0.06FY2026 – $-0.35FY2026
EPS growth, the year after +2,350.0% – –
Revenue, next fiscal year $21.87BFY2026 – $8.72BFY2026
Revenue growth, next FY +17.5%FY2026 – -2.1%FY2026
Revenue growth, the year after +2.4% – -6.1%

Institutional Ownership

13F filings, quarter ended Jun 30, 2026
HoldersCLFMSBSID
Held by institutions 83.1% 50.3% 2.1%
Institutions holding 585 63 66
Change in shares held, QoQ +1.4% -1.0% -22.1%
Institutions buying 280 28 27
Institutions selling 192 16 24
Buyers to sellers 1.46 1.75 1.13

Return Correlation

Daily returns, last 12 months

1.00 means two stocks move in lockstep, 0 that they move independently. Pairs below about 0.5 diversify each other.

CLFMSBSID
CLF 1.00 0.18 0.33
MSB 0.18 1.00 0.14
SID 0.33 0.14 1.00

Add a Peer

Largest companies in the same industry

Related Comparisons

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is bigger, CLF, MSB and SID?

Cleveland-Cliffs (CLF) is the largest by market capitalisation: Cleveland-Cliffs (CLF) $6.76B, Mesabi Trust (MSB) $209.40M, National Steel (SID) $832.92M.

Which company is growing faster?

National Steel (SID) grew revenue fastest over the trailing twelve months: Cleveland-Cliffs (CLF) +7.8%, Mesabi Trust (MSB) -87.6%, National Steel (SID) +23.4%.

Which company is more profitable?

Mesabi Trust (MSB) has the highest net margin (Cleveland-Cliffs (CLF) -2.4%, Mesabi Trust (MSB) 54.5%, National Steel (SID) -1.8%).

Which stock has performed better?

Over the past year Cleveland-Cliffs (CLF) returned the most: Cleveland-Cliffs (CLF) +12.8%, Mesabi Trust (MSB) -54.4%, National Steel (SID) -61.5%. Over five years, Mesabi Trust (MSB) compounded fastest (Cleveland-Cliffs (CLF) -10.8%/yr, Mesabi Trust (MSB) -8.2%/yr, National Steel (SID) -30.4%/yr). Returns are price only, before dividends.

Which stock is riskier?

By one-year price volatility, Mesabi Trust (MSB) has been the steadiest (Cleveland-Cliffs (CLF) 66.9%, Mesabi Trust (MSB) 45.9%, National Steel (SID) 75.2%). Volatility measures how widely the price swings, not the risk of the business.

Which is the better stock, CLF, MSB and SID?

There is no single answer; it depends on what you are buying for. On the 12 head-to-head measures on this page, Mesabi Trust (MSB) leads on 4. Business Quant does not give investment advice; use the comparison as a starting point for your own research.

Data from SEC filings, exchange prices and consensus estimates, via Business Quant. Percentile scores compare each company with its own peer group, so two companies' scores are each relative to different peers unless you rank against the whole market. Price returns exclude dividends. Nothing on this page is investment advice.