Choiceone Financial Services Inc (NASDAQ: COFS)

Sector: Financial Services Industry: Banks - Regional CIK: 0000803164
Market Cap 461.95 Mn
P/B 1.03
P/E 21.52
P/S 3.58
ROIC (Qtr) 3.05
Div Yield % 4.78
Rev 1y % (Qtr) 80.40
Total Debt (Qtr) 246.12 Mn
Debt/Equity (Qtr) 0.55

About

ChoiceOne Financial Services, Inc. (COFS), a company operating in the financial industry, is a financial holding company that primarily engages in the banking business through its subsidiary, ChoiceOne Bank. The company's operations are based in western and southeastern Michigan. ChoiceOne Financial Services, Inc. operates through three main segments: Banking, Insurance Agency, and Fintech. The Banking segment is the company's core business, generating the majority of its revenue. ChoiceOne Bank provides a range of deposit, payment, credit, and...

Read more

Price action

Investment thesis

Bull case

  • Strong tangible asset base of 4.14B provides 16.81x coverage of total debt 246.12M, indicating robust asset backing and low credit risk.
  • Operating cash flow of 41.79M provides strong 52.04x coverage of stock compensation 803000, indicating sustainable incentive practices.
  • Robust free cash flow of 36.62M exceeds capital expenditure of 5.17M by 7.08x, indicating strong organic growth funding capability.
  • Strong tangible asset base of 4.14B provides 23.91x coverage of acquisition spending 173.08M, enabling strategic growth.
  • Strong tangible asset base of 4.14B provides 26.12x coverage of intangibles 158.42M, indicating robust asset quality.

Bear case

  • Operating cash flow of 41.79M barely covers its investment activities of 183.29M, with a coverage ratio of 0.23, indicating heavy reliance on external financing for growth which may not be sustainable in a tighter credit environment.
  • Operating cash flow of 41.79M provides thin coverage of dividend payments of (15.11M) with a -2.77 ratio, suggesting potential dividend sustainability issues if operational performance deteriorates.
  • Cash reserves of 98.98M provide limited coverage of acquisition spending of 173.08M, which is 0.57x, suggesting aggressive expansion might strain liquidity if market conditions deteriorate.
  • Operating earnings of 26.20M show weak coverage of depreciation charges of 17.71M, with a 1.48 ratio indicating high capital intensity and potential reinvestment needs.
  • Free cash flow of 36.62M represents just -0.20x of debt issuance (182.32M), suggesting concerning reliance on leverage rather than internal cash generation for growth.

Peer comparison

Companies in the Banks - Regional
S.No. Ticker Company Market Cap P/E P/S Total Debt (Qtr)
1 USB Us Bancorp \De\ 84.44 Bn 12.40 3.25 77.98 Bn
2 PNC Pnc Financial Services Group, Inc. 84.36 Bn 13.61 3.73 62.34 Bn
3 NU Nu Holdings Ltd. 81.47 Bn 32.21 5.79 4.49 Bn
4 NWG NatWest Group plc 66.53 Bn 9.88 3.05 169.04 Bn
5 TFC Truist Financial Corp 64.60 Bn 13.18 3.53 71.11 Bn
6 MTB M&T Bank Corp 32.73 Bn 12.47 3.60 14.99 Bn
7 FITB Fifth Third Bancorp 31.96 Bn 14.15 3.93 18.94 Bn
8 FCNCA First Citizens Bancshares Inc /De/ 28.98 Bn 12.78 3.26 40.00 Bn

Industry comparisons

Current Valuation Value Ind Avg Percentile
EV to Assets EV to Assets 0.13 0.14
EV to Cash from Ops. EV/CFO 13.22 7.21
EV to Debt EV to Debt 2.24 5.20
EV to EBIT EV/EBIT 21.08 14.98
EV to EBITDA EV/EBITDA 12.58 8.92
EV to Free Cash Flow [EV/FCF] EV/FCF 15.08 8.87
EV to Market Cap EV to Market Cap 1.20 1.04
EV to Revenue EV/Rev 4.28 -3.76
Price to Book Value [P/B] P/B 1.03 1.17
Price to Earnings [P/E] P/E 21.52 15.63
Dividend Metrics Value Ind Avg Percentile
Dividend Coverage Ratio Div Coverage (Qtr) 1.42 271.44
Dividend Payout Ratio % Div Payout % (Qtr) 81.80 35.28
Dividend per Basic Share Div per Share (Qtr) 1.12 0.89
FCF Dividend Payout Ratio % FCF Div Payout % (Qtr) 45.92 34.52
Interest Coverage Interest Coverage 0.00 -0.05
Growth Metrics Value Ind Avg Percentile
Capex Growth (1y) % Capex 1y % (Qtr) -182.92 -73.15
Cash and Equivalents Growth (1y) % Cash & Equiv 1y % (Qtr) -32.18 15.78
Dividend Growth (1y) % Div 1y % (Qtr) 3.70 5.32
EBIAT Growth (1y) % EBIAT 1y % (Qtr) -13.65 110.93
EBITDA Growth (1y) % EBITDA 1y % (Qtr) 2.15 38.80
EBIT Growth (1y) % EBIT 1y % (Qtr) -14.77 61.46
EBT Growth (1y) % EBT 1y % (Qtr) -14.77 61.37
EPS Growth (1y) % EPS 1y % (Qtr) -56.92 76.34
FCF Growth (1y) % FCF 1y % (Qtr) 232.33 161.72
Gross Profit Growth (1y) % Gross Profit 1y % (Qtr) 46.68 14.15
Liquidity Ratios Value Ind Avg Percentile
Asset Utilization Ratio Asset Util Ratio (Qtr) 0.03 0.04
Cash Payout Ratio Cash Payout (Qtr) 0.32 0.26
Cash Ratio Cash Ratio 0.00 0.00
Current Ratio Current Ratio 0.00 0.01
Debt to Equity Ratio Debt/Equity (Qtr) 0.55 0.53
Interest Cover Ratio Interest Cover Ratio 0.00 -0.05
Times Interest Earned Times Interest Earned 0.00 -0.05
Profitability Value Ind Avg Percentile
EBITDA Margin % EBITDA Margin % (Qtr) 34.10 147.97
EBIT Margin % EBIT Margin % (Qtr) 20.32 155.41
EBT Margin % EBT Margin % (Qtr) 20.32 154.66
Gross Margin % Gross Margin % (Qtr) 100.00 97.82
Net Profit Margin % Net Margin % (Qtr) 16.70 115.63