Selective Insurance (SIGI) Operating Margin (2009 - 2026)

Selective Insurance has disclosed Operating Margin across 18 years of filings, most recently posting 10.48% for Q1 2026.

• Operating Margin for Q1 2026 came in at 10.48%, up 109.0% year-over-year; the trailing twelve-month figure through Mar 2026 was 10.22% (down 84.0% YoY), and the FY2025 annual result was 9.95%, down 49.0% from the prior year.
• Operating Margin came in at 10.48% for Q1 2026 at Selective Insurance, down from 10.54% in the prior quarter.
• In the past five years, Operating Margin ranged from a high of 15.92% in Q4 2024 to a low of 7.14% in Q3 2022.
• The 5-year median for Operating Margin is 9.39% (2025), against an average of 9.85%.
• Across the five-year window, Operating Margin surged 219 bps in 2023 and tumbled 539 bps in 2025, its largest moves.
• Selective Insurance's Operating Margin stood at 7.14% in 2022, then soared by 31 bps to 9.33% in 2023, then jumped by 71 bps to 15.92% in 2024, then plunged by 34 bps to 10.54% in 2025, then slipped by 1 bps to 10.48% in 2026.
• The last three Operating Margin figures came in at 10.48% (Q1 2026), 10.54% (Q4 2025), and 10.19% (Q3 2025), per Business Quant data.