Selective Insurance (SIGI) Operating Income (2009 - 2026)

Selective Insurance (SIGI) posted Operating Income of $142.4 million for Q1 2026, down 1.01% sequentially from $143.8 million in Q4 2025, and up 17.97% YoY from $120.7 million in Q1 2025.

Selective Insurance (SIGI) Operating Income (2009 - 2026) Analysis & Trends

Selective Insurance (SIGI) has 18 years of Operating Income data on file, last reported at $142.4 million in Q1 2026.

  • Quarterly Operating Income rose 17.97% year-over-year to $142.4 million in Q1 2026, while the trailing twelve-month figure through Mar 2026 was $552.8 million (up 17.65% YoY) and the FY2025 annual result came in at $531.2 million, up 16.21% from the prior year.
  • Operating Income declined to $142.4 million in Q1 2026 per SIGI's latest filing, from $143.8 million in the prior quarter.
  • The five-year high for Operating Income was $143.8 million in Q4 2025, with the low at $63.9 million in Q3 2022.
  • Average Operating Income over 5 years is $108.5 million, with a median of $108.6 million recorded in 2024.
  • Year-over-year, Operating Income sank 31.33% in 2022 and soared 57.87% in 2023.
  • Selective Insurance's Operating Income stood at $63.9 million in 2022, then surged by 57.87% to $100.9 million in 2023, then gained by 21.75% to $122.8 million in 2024, then advanced by 17.13% to $143.8 million in 2025, then fell by 1.01% to $142.4 million in 2026.
  • Business Quant data shows SIGI's Operating Income at $142.4 million in Q1 2026, $143.8 million in Q4 2025, and $138.7 million in Q3 2025.

Peer Comparison

# Company Market Cap Enterprise Value Gross Profit (Qtr) Op. Inc (Qtr)
1 Markel 7,105.55 Bn 7,090.09 Bn 2.38 Bn -273.33 Mn
2 Progressive 131.92 Bn 127.57 Bn 8.36 Bn -10.26 Bn
3 Chubb 78.78 Bn 71.35 Bn 8.64 Bn 1.71 Bn
4 Cincinnati Financial 74.32 Bn 73.06 Bn 2.60 Bn 318.00 Mn
5 Travelers Companies 72.03 Bn 48.11 Bn 5.54 Bn 1.01 Bn
6 Allstate 63.08 Bn 38.49 Bn 14.72 Bn 938.00 Mn
7 Fairfax Financial Holdings 34.53 Bn 39.18 Bn - -
8 Loews 23.53 Bn 11.27 Bn -1.32 Bn 613.00 Mn
9 Selective Insurance 20.82 Bn 19.07 Bn 543.42 Mn 142.38 Mn
10 Assurant 13.63 Bn 11.71 Bn 2.01 Bn 159.60 Mn

Historic Data

Download Data
DateValue
Mar 31, 2026 142.38 Mn
Dec 31, 2025 143.84 Mn
Sep 30, 2025 138.66 Mn
Jun 30, 2025 127.97 Mn
Mar 31, 2025 120.69 Mn
Dec 31, 2024 122.80 Mn
Sep 30, 2024 117.76 Mn
Jun 30, 2024 108.64 Mn
Mar 31, 2024 107.85 Mn
Sep 30, 2023 100.86 Mn
Jun 30, 2023 97.70 Mn
Mar 31, 2023 91.51 Mn
Sep 30, 2022 63.89 Mn
Jun 30, 2022 70.22 Mn
Mar 31, 2022 72.60 Mn
Sep 30, 2021 93.03 Mn
Jun 30, 2021 83.73 Mn
Mar 31, 2021 69.72 Mn
Dec 31, 2020 68.51 Mn
Sep 30, 2020 68.19 Mn