ACGL vs PGR vs ALL Stock Comparison

Arch Capital, Progressive and Allstate Prices as of Nov 13, 2026 Peers: Industry group
ACGL Arch Capital Group Ltd.
$109.61 +12.3% 1M +18.2% 1Y
Market cap
$37.25B
P/E
8.6x
Revenue (TTM)
$18.78B
Div. yield
0.00%
Property and Casualty Insurance Financial Services
2 wins
PGR Progressive Corp/Oh/
$235.76 +10.4% 1M +5.7% 1Y
Market cap
$137.93B
P/E
11.9x
Revenue (TTM)
$91.74B
Div. yield
0.06%
Property and Casualty Insurance Financial Services
4 wins
ALL Allstate Corp
$267.70 +13.4% 1M +26.8% 1Y
Market cap
$68.12B
P/E
5.9x
Revenue (TTM)
$17.61B
Div. yield
0.02%
Property and Casualty Insurance Financial Services
6 wins

Head to Head

12 decided of 12

Allstate leads on 6 of the 12 questions below (Allstate 6, Progressive 4, Arch Capital 2). Which ones matter depends on what you are buying for; a cheap multiple and slow growth often come together.

QuestionACGLPGRALLLeader
Larger companyMarket capitalisation $37.25B $137.93B $68.12B PGR
Cheaper on earningsLower P/E, profitable companies only 8.6x 11.9x 5.9x ALL
Cheaper on forward earningsLower price / next fiscal year consensus EPS 10.3x 13.3x 6.6x ALL
Faster revenue growthRevenue growth, trailing twelve months -3.9% +7.7% +6.0% PGR
More profitableNet margin, trailing twelve months 23.1% 12.7% 65.4% ALL
Better return on capitalReturn on invested capital 15.7% 28.2% 9.7% PGR
Less leveragedLower net debt / EBITDA — 0.2x -0.6x ALL
Higher dividend yieldTrailing dividend yield 0.00% 0.06% 0.02% PGR
Better 1-year returnPrice return, last 12 months +18.2% +5.7% +26.8% ALL
Better 5-year returnAnnualised price return, 5 years +21.2%/yr +19.7%/yr +18.5%/yr ACGL
Less volatileAnnualised volatility, 1 year 21.2% 27.6% 26.3% ACGL
Higher overall scoreMean of the five percentile scores vs peers 68/100 64/100 78/100 ALL

Percentile Scorecard

ACGLPGRALL

Each axis is the mean percentile of its metrics against the company's industry group. 100 is the best in the group, 50 the middle.

Scores by Axis

AxisACGLPGRALL
Valuation 66 #42 of 121 43 #70 of 121 59 #50 of 121
Growth 33 #80 of 118 57 #51 of 118 86 #18 of 118
Profitability 81 #23 of 119 75 #30 of 119 90 #13 of 119
Financial Health 80 #24 of 118 70 #36 of 118 71 #35 of 118
Shareholder Returns 81 #22 of 111 75 #29 of 111 86 #16 of 111
Overall 68 64 78
  • ACGL ranked among 127 companies in Insurance
  • PGR ranked among 127 companies in Insurance
  • ALL ranked among 127 companies in Insurance

Price Performance

Price return, split-adjusted, before dividends. Click a name to hide or show it.

Returns

PeriodACGLPGRALLSPY
1 month +12.3%+10.4%+13.4% -2.0%
3 months +11.0%+12.5%+2.4% -2.8%
6 months +16.6%+18.0%+23.2% +2.0%
Year to date +14.3%+3.5%+28.6% +10.6%
1 year +18.2%+5.7%+26.8% +12.2%
3 years +28.2%+47.8%+103.3% +68.1%
3 years, per year +8.6%+13.9%+26.7% +18.9%
5 years +160.9%+145.1%+133.4% +61.4%
5 years, per year +21.2%+19.7%+18.5% +10.1%
10 years +305.4%+609.9%+284.4% +248.5%
10 years, per year +15.0%+21.7%+14.4% +13.3%

Risk

MeasureACGLPGRALLSPY
Volatility, 1Y 21.2%27.6%26.3% 13.6%
Downside volatility, 1Y 22.6%30.2%27.4% 13.9%
Beta vs S&P 500, 1Y -0.28-0.40-0.37 1.00
Return / volatility, 1Y 0.860.211.02 0.90
Max drawdown, 5Y -26.2%-34.6%-29.7% -25.4%
From 52-week high -1.0%-0.3%-2.7% -3.2%
52-week high $110.68$236.36$275.13 $779.14
52-week low $87.62$190.40$192.28 $631.97

Valuation History

Weekly multiples on trailing twelve-month fundamentals. Negative or extreme readings (a loss year, a collapsed denominator) are left out so the chart stays readable.

MultipleACGLPGRALL
P/E now vs peer median 8.5xmedian 11.0x 11.8xmedian 11.0x 5.8xmedian 11.0x
P/S now vs peer median 1.9xmedian 1.5x 1.5xmedian 1.5x 3.8xmedian 1.5x
EV/EBITDA now vs peer median —median 7.5x 9.0xmedian 7.5x 11.8xmedian 7.5x
P/FCF now vs peer median 6.3xmedian 8.1x 9.0xmedian 8.1x 5.2xmedian 8.1x
P/B now vs peer median 1.6xmedian 1.5x 4.0xmedian 1.5x 2.1xmedian 1.5x
PEG now vs peer median 0.47median 0.53 0.19median 0.53 0.06median 0.53

Financial History

Reported figures by fiscal period, placed on the calendar year (or quarter) each period ended in, so companies with different fiscal years line up.

Trailing twelve monthsACGLPGRALL
Revenue $18.78B $91.74B $17.61B
Gross profit $10.01B $34.33B -$19.12B
Operating income $5.04B $15.28B $5.00B
Net income $4.38B $11.62B $11.64B
Free cash flow $5.63B $15.22B $12.73B
EPS (diluted) $12.70 $19.96 $45.13
Cash & equivalents $1.15B $156.00M $549.00M
Total debt $4.30B $8.39B $7.49B
Shares (diluted) 341.40M 582.20M 255.30M
Enterprise value $24.78B $113.45B $25.19B

All Metrics

58 metrics · best in bold

Bold marks the best reading: the lowest positive value for multiples, leverage and payout, the highest for everything else. The bar under each value is its percentile against that company's own peers. Hover a value for its rank and the peer median.

Valuation

12 metrics
MetricACGLPGRALL
P/E 8.5x 11.8x 5.8x
P/FCF 6.3x 9.0x 5.2x
P/Operating cash flow 6.3x 8.7x 5.1x
P/S 1.9x 1.5x 3.8x
P/B 1.6x 4.0x 2.1x
P/Tangible book 1.6x 4.0x 2.1x
EV/EBITDA – 9.0x 11.8x
EV/EBIT 7.2x 9.2x 12.7x
EV/Revenue 1.9x 1.5x 3.6x
EV/FCF 6.5x 9.2x 5.0x
EV/Operating cash flow 6.4x 8.9x 4.9x
PEG (3Y EPS CAGR) 0.47 0.19 0.06

Growth

14 metrics
MetricACGLPGRALL
Revenue growth (1Y) -3.9% 7.7% 6.0%
Revenue CAGR (3Y) 14.8% 16.1% -32.0%
Gross profit growth (1Y) -0.6% 6.1% 13.6%
Gross profit CAGR (3Y) 15.1% 35.1% –
Operating income growth (1Y) 7.7% 3.7% 100.7%
Operating income CAGR (3Y) 45.6% 60.6% –
Net income growth (1Y) 6.9% 8.5% 38.9%
Net income CAGR (3Y) 13.8% 61.8% 98.6%
EPS growth (1Y) 17.8% 9.6% 45.5%
EPS CAGR (3Y) 18.1% 63.0% 97.3%
Operating cash flow growth (1Y) -10.5% -9.9% 46.9%
Operating cash flow CAGR (3Y) 3.8% 19.7% 48.3%
Free cash flow growth (1Y) -10.6% -10.7% 47.4%
Free cash flow CAGR (3Y) 3.9% 19.5% 50.9%

Profitability

14 metrics
MetricACGLPGRALL
Gross margin 53.3% 37.4% -108.6%
EBITDA margin – 17.0% 30.5%
Operating margin 26.8% 16.7% 28.4%
Pretax margin 25.9% 16.0% 84.0%
Net margin 23.1% 12.7% 65.4%
FCF margin 30.0% 16.6% 72.3%
Operating cash flow margin 30.2% 17.1% 73.7%
Return on equity 17.9% 33.8% 367.0%
Return on assets 5.0% 9.2% 95.9%
Return on invested capital 15.7% 28.2% 9.7%
Return on capital employed – – –
Asset turnover 0.2x 0.7x 0.1x
Cash conversion (OCF / net income) 1.3x 1.3x 1.1x
Stock comp / revenue 0.8% 0.1% –

Financial Health

11 metrics
MetricACGLPGRALL
Debt / assets 5.1% 6.6% 5.9%
Debt / equity 0.2x 0.2x 0.2x
Net debt / EBITDA – 0.2x -0.6x
Debt / FCF 0.8x 0.6x 0.6x
Liabilities / assets 72.7% 73.0% 74.7%
Equity / assets 27.3% 27.0% 25.3%
Interest coverage 27.8x 26.0x 12.8x
Current ratio – – –
Quick ratio – – –
Cash ratio – – –
Altman Z-score – – –

Shareholder Returns

7 metrics
MetricACGLPGRALL
Dividend yield 0.0% 5.9% 1.6%
Net buyback yield 11.6% 1.1% 4.9%
Shareholder yield 11.6% 7.0% 6.5%
Payout ratio (earnings) 0.1% 70.1% 9.3%
Payout ratio (FCF) 0.1% 53.5% 8.5%
Dividend growth (1Y) -99.7% 183.8% 6.2%
Dividend CAGR (3Y) – 226.5% 5.5%

Analyst Estimates

Solid lines are reported fiscal-year results; dashed lines are the consensus for the years ahead. Hover a year for the analysts' high and low, and how each result compared with its estimate.

ConsensusACGLPGRALL
Forward P/E 10.3xFY2026 13.3xFY2026 6.6xFY2026
EPS, next fiscal year $10.60FY2026 $17.69FY2026 $40.76FY2026
EPS growth, next FY +7.4%FY2026 -2.0%FY2026 +17.0%FY2026
EPS growth, the year after -10.8% -11.2% -33.6%
Revenue, next fiscal year $16.58BFY2026 $91.75BFY2026 $65.06BFY2026
Revenue growth, next FY +0.6%FY2026 +10.3%FY2026 +9.3%FY2026
Revenue growth, the year after -5.3% -4.9% -6.0%

Institutional Ownership

13F filings, quarter ended Jun 30, 2026
HoldersACGLPGRALL
Held by institutions 91.0% 87.2% 82.8%
Institutions holding 905 1,827 1,754
Change in shares held, QoQ -1.7% +0.5% +0.0%
Institutions buying 428 895 871
Institutions selling 365 696 535
Buyers to sellers 1.17 1.29 1.63

Return Correlation

Daily returns, last 12 months

1.00 means two stocks move in lockstep, 0 that they move independently. Pairs below about 0.5 diversify each other.

ACGLPGRALL
ACGL 1.00 0.62 0.72
PGR 0.62 1.00 0.72
ALL 0.72 0.72 1.00

Add a Peer

Largest companies in the same industry

Related Comparisons

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is bigger, ACGL, PGR and ALL?

Progressive (PGR) is the largest by market capitalisation: Arch Capital (ACGL) $37.25B, Progressive (PGR) $137.93B, Allstate (ALL) $68.12B.

Which stock is cheaper, ACGL, PGR and ALL?

Allstate (ALL) trades on the lowest price-to-earnings ratio (Arch Capital (ACGL) 8.6x, Progressive (PGR) 11.9x, Allstate (ALL) 5.9x). On next year's consensus earnings, Allstate (ALL) is cheapest (Arch Capital (ACGL) 10.3x, Progressive (PGR) 13.3x, Allstate (ALL) 6.6x). A lower multiple can reflect slower expected growth, so read it next to the growth figures.

Which company is growing faster?

Progressive (PGR) grew revenue fastest over the trailing twelve months: Arch Capital (ACGL) -3.9%, Progressive (PGR) +7.7%, Allstate (ALL) +6.0%.

Which company is more profitable?

Allstate (ALL) has the highest net margin (Arch Capital (ACGL) 23.1%, Progressive (PGR) 12.7%, Allstate (ALL) 65.4%). On return on invested capital, Progressive (PGR) leads (Arch Capital (ACGL) 15.7%, Progressive (PGR) 28.2%, Allstate (ALL) 9.7%).

Which stock has performed better?

Over the past year Allstate (ALL) returned the most: Arch Capital (ACGL) +18.2%, Progressive (PGR) +5.7%, Allstate (ALL) +26.8%. Over five years, Arch Capital (ACGL) compounded fastest (Arch Capital (ACGL) +21.2%/yr, Progressive (PGR) +19.7%/yr, Allstate (ALL) +18.5%/yr). Returns are price only, before dividends.

Which pays a higher dividend?

Progressive (PGR) has the highest dividend yield: Arch Capital (ACGL) 0.00%, Progressive (PGR) 0.06%, Allstate (ALL) 0.02%.

Which stock is riskier?

By one-year price volatility, Arch Capital (ACGL) has been the steadiest (Arch Capital (ACGL) 21.2%, Progressive (PGR) 27.6%, Allstate (ALL) 26.3%). Volatility measures how widely the price swings, not the risk of the business.

Which is the better stock, ACGL, PGR and ALL?

There is no single answer; it depends on what you are buying for. On the 12 head-to-head measures on this page, Allstate (ALL) leads on 6. Business Quant does not give investment advice; use the comparison as a starting point for your own research.

Data from SEC filings, exchange prices and consensus estimates, via Business Quant. Percentile scores compare each company with its own peer group, so two companies' scores are each relative to different peers unless you rank against the whole market. Price returns exclude dividends. Nothing on this page is investment advice.