Nicolet Bankshares NIC Insider Ownership

NYSE NIC

$163.78 -2.97 (-1.78%)

As of: Sep 29, 2026 · 3:59 PM EDT

Insider Holdings by Owner

1.04Mn Shares

Insider Ownership Statistics

as of 30 Sep, 2026

Insider Ownership

9.02%

▼-0.080% pp QoQ

Shares Held by Insiders

1.91Mn

filed for Sep 2026

▼-0.88% QoQ

Shares Outstanding

21.21Mn

21,208,000 shares

Direct Holdings

1.74Mn

Indirect: 173.04K

Net Shares Traded (QoQ)

-17.06K

net selling in Sep 2026

Insiders Holding Shares

with Form 4 holdings on file

Shares Owned by Insiders

Shares held % of outstanding

Latest —

Average ownership —

Peak ownership —

Shares Purchased/Sold by Insiders

Bought Sold

Latest quarter —

Net over range —

Buying quarters —

Insider Ownership Summary

Quarter ending 30 Sep, 2026

Nicolet Bankshares's top three insider shareholders as of September 29, 2026 are Brenda L Johnson (Director, 671.89K shares), Oliver Pierce Smith (Director, 446.12K shares), Michael E Daniels (Chairman, President Ceo, 126.84K shares).

A detailed ownership breakdown for Nicolet Bankshares is not available at this time.
According to Business Quant data, insider ownership at Nicolet Bankshares stands at 910.20%, comprising 1.93Mn shares out of 21.21Mn total outstanding.
Their combined stake in NIC fell 0.80%, moving from 1.95Mn shares to 1.93Mn shares.
Among insider personnel at Nicolet Bankshares, Robert Bruce Atwell (Director) bought the most shares, adding 7.50K shares in the 90-day window ending September 29, 2026.
On the flip side, Robert Bruce Atwell (Director) was the biggest seller at NIC, selling 15.00K shares in the 90 days through September 29, 2026.

Form 4 Holdings

Insiders Holding NIC

Insiders 28

Shares held 1.04Mn

Of outstanding 4.88%

#	Insider	Position	Direct	Indirect	Total	Share of Insiders	Last Filed
1	Oliver Pierce Smith	Director	446,116	0	446,116	43.1%	21 May, 2026
2	Michael E Daniels	Chairman, President Ceo	65,389	61,452	126,841	12.3%	07 May, 2026
3	Donald J Jr Long	Director	80,963	0	80,963	7.8%	17 Aug, 2026
4	Susan L Merkatoris	Director	78,946	0	78,946	7.6%	21 May, 2026
5	Hubert Phillip Jr Moore	Cfo	37,921	0	37,921	3.7%	10 Jun, 2026
6	Brad Vincent Hutjens	Evp Cco Nicolet Natl Bank	35,530	0	35,530	3.4%	17 Feb, 2026
7	Robert Bruce Atwell	Executive Chairman	34,483	0	34,483	3.3%	28 Jul, 2026
8	Eric James Witczak	Evp Retail Ag Banking	33,288	0	33,288	3.2%	29 Jul, 2026
9	Tracy S Mccormick	Director	30,226	0	30,226	2.9%	21 May, 2026
10	Ann Kuchera Lawson	Chief Financial Officer	27,479	0	27,479	2.7%	19 May, 2022
11	Paul Davison Tobias	Director	23,930	0	23,930	2.3%	19 May, 2022
12	William M Bohn	Evp Wealth Mgmt Nicolet Bank	16,585	0	16,585	1.6%	17 Apr, 2026
13	Lynn Dale Davis	Director	12,304	0	12,304	1.2%	21 May, 2025
14	Robert J Weyers	Director	0	10,260	10,260	1.0%	26 May, 2026
15	John Nicholas Dykema	Director	0	10,223	10,223	1.0%	26 May, 2026
16	Patrick Joseph Madson	Svp Wealth Mgmt Nicoletnatbank	5,032	0	5,032	0.5%	18 Dec, 2023
17	Matthew J Hayek	Director	4,492	0	4,492	0.4%	21 May, 2026
18	Janet E Godwin	Director	3,793	0	3,793	0.4%	21 May, 2026
19	Christopher J. Ghidorzi	Director	0	3,376	3,376	0.3%	21 Jan, 2026
20	Eric Peter Radzak	Corp Dev Off Nicolet Nat Bank	2,775	0	2,775	0.3%	09 May, 2022
21	Glen E Tellock	Director	2,357	0	2,357	0.2%	21 May, 2026
22	Andrew F Jr Hetzel	Director	0	1,946	1,946	0.2%	17 Jul, 2025
23	Dustin James Mcclone	Director	0	1,862	1,862	0.2%	21 Jan, 2026
24	Terrence R Fulwiler	Director	0	1,721	1,721	0.2%	21 Apr, 2022
25	Hector Colon	Director	0	1,060	1,060	0.1%	21 Jan, 2026
26	Brenda L Johnson	Director	0	897	897	0.1%	21 Jan, 2026
27	Carl J Chaney	Director	0	498	498	0.0%	26 May, 2026
28	Marcia M Anderson	Director	0	412	412	0.0%	21 Jan, 2026

Each row is that insider’s most recently reported position, from Form 4 filings over the last 60 months — which is why this total does not tie to the quarterly series above, where a quarter counts only the insiders who filed in it. Shares held through a fund or institutional portfolio are counted on the institutional ownership page instead.

Form 4 Filings

1,402 Insider Transactions

Source SEC Form 4

Latest quarter Sep 2026

Date	Insider	Position	Transaction	Shares	Price	Value	Shares Held After	Ownership
13 Aug, 2026	Donald J Jr Long	Director	Disposed G	150	$0.00	$0	80,963	Direct
27 Jul, 2026	Eric James Witczak	Evp Retail Ag Banking	Disposed S	1,215	$167.89	$203.99K	33,630	Direct
28 Jul, 2026	Eric James Witczak	Evp Retail Ag Banking	Disposed S	342	$171.96	$58.81K	33,288	Direct
24 Jul, 2026	Robert Bruce Atwell	Director	Acquired M	7,500	$56.43	$423.23K	41,983	Direct
24 Jul, 2026	Robert Bruce Atwell	Director	Disposed F	4,838	$170.85	$826.57K	37,145	Direct
24 Jul, 2026	Robert Bruce Atwell	Director	Disposed S	2,662	$170.24	$453.18K	34,483	Direct
24 Jul, 2026	Robert Bruce Atwell	Director	Disposed M	7,500	$0.00	$0	40,000	Direct
08 Jun, 2026	Hubert Phillip Jr Moore	Cfo	Disposed F	940	$144.06	$135.42K	37,921	Direct
19 May, 2026	Carl J Chaney	Director	Acquired A	498	$139.63	$69.49K	498	Indirect
19 May, 2026	John Nicholas Dykema	Director	Acquired A	551	$139.63	$76.98K	10,223	Indirect
19 May, 2026	Robert Bruce Atwell	Director	Acquired A	498	$139.63	$69.49K	1,066	Indirect
19 May, 2026	Donald J Jr Long	Director	Acquired A	569	$139.63	$79.48K	6,186	Indirect
19 May, 2026	Robert J Weyers	Director	Acquired A	458	$139.63	$63.99K	10,260	Indirect
19 May, 2026	Donald J Jr Long	Director	Acquired A	429	$139.63	$59.90K	81,113	Direct
19 May, 2026	Robert Bruce Atwell	Director	Acquired A	429	$139.63	$59.90K	34,483	Direct
19 May, 2026	Robert J Weyers	Director	Acquired A	429	$139.63	$59.90K	52,989	Direct
19 May, 2026	Janet E Godwin	Director	Acquired A	429	$139.63	$59.90K	3,793	Direct
19 May, 2026	Carl J Chaney	Director	Acquired A	429	$139.63	$59.90K	1,196	Direct
19 May, 2026	Matthew J Hayek	Director	Acquired A	429	$139.63	$59.90K	4,492	Direct
19 May, 2026	Glen E Tellock	Director	Acquired A	429	$139.63	$59.90K	2,357	Direct

Showing 1 to 20 of 1,402 transactions