According to recent filings covering the 90 days ending February 19, 2026, the three most significant insider holders at American Financial are Co Ceo & Co President Carl H Iii Lindner (3.14Mn shares), Co Ceo & Co President S Craig Lindner (2.86Mn shares), President Of Subsidiary David Lawrence Jr Thompson (591.34K shares).
| Holder | Position | Shares | Report Date |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carl H Iii Lindner | Co Ceo & Co President | 3,142,584 | 24 May, 2021 |
| S Craig Lindner | Co Ceo & Co President | 2,860,721 | 17 May, 2021 |
| David Lawrence Jr Thompson | President Of Subsidiary | 591,340 | 22 Dec, 2025 |
| John B Berding | President | 120,430 | 25 Feb, 2025 |
| James E Evans | 109,253 | 04 Jun, 2024 | |
| Vito C Peraino | Senior Vp & Executive Counsel | 81,050 | 22 May, 2023 |
| Gregory G Joseph | 47,931 | 02 Jun, 2025 | |
| Mark A Weiss | Sr. Vp & General Counsel | 18,834 | 25 Feb, 2025 |
| William W Verity | 13,119 | 02 Jun, 2025 | |
| Michelle A Gillis | Senior Vice President | 13,100 | 30 Dec, 2025 |
| Virginia Drosos | 12,619 | 02 Jun, 2021 | |
| Lehman John I Von | 12,463 | 02 Jun, 2025 | |
| Brian S. Hertzman | Svp And Cfo | 11,300 | 10 Nov, 2025 |
| Stephen Craig Jr Lindner | 10,327 | 29 Jan, 2026 | |
| Mary Beth Martin | 10,194 | 02 Jun, 2025 | |
| Terry S Jacobs | 7,500 | 13 Jun, 2023 | |
| Evans N Nwankwo | 6,347 | 01 Jun, 2025 | |
| Amy Y Murray | 3,851 | 04 Sep, 2025 | |
| Roger K Newport | 3,662 | 02 Jun, 2025 |
* Please note that the shares above only reflect shares from the fund portfolio and the institutional portfolio. Shares from the personal portfolio are excluded from this Institutional Ownership Page. See these insiders' latest transactions here on Insider Page.
| Transaction Date | Insider Name | Security Class | Transaction Type | Shares Traded | Price | Shares Remaining | Ownership | Code |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 28 Jan, 2026 | Stephen Craig Jr Lindner | Common Stock | A | 276 | $0.00 | 326,535 | I | G |
| 28 Jan, 2026 | Stephen Craig Jr Lindner | Common Stock | A | 147 | $0.00 | 10,327 | I | G |
| 28 Jan, 2026 | Stephen Craig Jr Lindner | Common Stock | A | 441 | $0.00 | 53,620 | I | G |
| 29 Dec, 2025 | Michelle A Gillis | Common Stock | D | 542 | $0.00 | 13,100 | D | G |
| 29 Dec, 2025 | Michelle A Gillis | - | - | 13,100 | D | |||
| 18 Dec, 2025 | David Lawrence Jr Thompson | - | - | 591,340 | I | |||
| 18 Dec, 2025 | David Lawrence Jr Thompson | Common Stock | D | 828 | $0.00 | 591,340 | I | G |
| 18 Dec, 2025 | Stephen Craig Jr Lindner | Common Stock | D | 44 | $0.00 | 326,388 | I | G |
| 16 Dec, 2025 | Carl H Iii Lindner | - | - | 3,142,584 | I | |||
| 16 Dec, 2025 | Carl H Iii Lindner | Common Stock | D | 403 | $0.00 | 3,142,584 | I | G |
| 15 Dec, 2025 | S Craig Lindner | Common Stock | D | 3,342 | $0.00 | 2,860,721 | I | G |
| 15 Dec, 2025 | S Craig Lindner | - | - | 2,860,721 | I | |||
| 15 Dec, 2025 | Stephen Craig Jr Lindner | Common Stock | A | 276 | $0.00 | 10,180 | I | G |
| 15 Dec, 2025 | Stephen Craig Jr Lindner | Common Stock | A | 828 | $0.00 | 53,179 | I | G |
| 15 Dec, 2025 | Stephen Craig Jr Lindner | Common Stock | A | 276 | $0.00 | 326,432 | I | G |
| 09 Dec, 2025 | Carl H Iii Lindner | Common Stock | D | 37,424 | $0.00 | 3,142,987 | I | G |
| 03 Dec, 2025 | Stephen Craig Jr Lindner | Common Stock | D | 574 | $0.00 | 326,156 | I | G |
| 03 Dec, 2025 | Stephen Craig Jr Lindner | Common Stock | A | 574 | $0.00 | 52,351 | I | G |
| 07 Nov, 2025 | Brian S. Hertzman | Common Stock | D | 1,777 | $142.51 | 11,300 | D | S |
| 07 Nov, 2025 | Brian S. Hertzman | - | - | 11,300 | D |